Skip to main content

OAKLAND, Calif. (


) -- After more than three weeks duking it out in a federal courthouse,



has been awarded $1.3 billion in damages from



after it sued its rival for software theft.



, which was announced late on Tuesday, ends a

headline-grabbing encounter

that saw

firebrand Oracle CEO Larry Ellison

and his CFO Safra Catz take the witness stand.

Oracle, however, was

unsuccessful in its attempts to subpoena

former SAP CEO Leo Apotheker, now in charge at



, to appear in the Oakland courthouse.

In his closing argument, Oracle's lawyer demanded $1.7 billion in damages from SAP,

according to media reports

. SAP, which had already admitted the theft by its

now-defunct TomorrowNow subsidiary

, offered to pay a sum closer to $40 million.

An SAP spokesman told

The San Jose Mercury News

that the German firm was disappointed with the verdict and was planning to examine its options, which could include an appeal.

Shares of Oracle rose 40 cents, or 1.47%, to $27.59 in extended trading on Tuesday, while SAP's stock fell 68 cents, or 1.4%, to $48.01.

--Written by James Rogers in New York.

>To follow the writer on Twitter, go to


>To submit a news tip, send an email to: