Investors wanted more meat on the bone from Costco Wholesale (COST) .

The warehouse king used its notorious cut-rate pricing on bulk food and surprising selection of higher end items to post an 8.4% same-store sales increase for the holiday season quarter. Earnings smashed through analyst estimates for the quarter ended Feb. 18, coming in at $1.59 a share vs. the $1.47 a share expected.

Even still, Wall Street sent Costco shares slightly lower on Thursday likely for several reasons.

First, what looked like a massive earnings beat was actually an earnings miss as the results included a 17 cent a share lift from the new tax reform plan. Further, like other retailers such as Target (TGT) and Walmart (WMT) that battled Action Alerts Plus holding Amazon (AMZN) online during the holidays, gross profit margins compressed. Costco's gross profit margin fell slightly from the prior year to 10.98%. 

With inflation starting to pickup, and margins already under pressure, Costco bulls could be wondering if it's time to ring the register. Before today's release, Costco's stock had risen 12% over the past year. 

More from Stocks

Facebook Jumps on $9 Billion Buyback Plan, Bullish Note From Deutsche Bank

Facebook Jumps on $9 Billion Buyback Plan, Bullish Note From Deutsche Bank

Nutrisystem Soars on Deal to Be Acquired by Tivity Health

Nutrisystem Soars on Deal to Be Acquired by Tivity Health

Apple Stock Overcomes Trade Troubles to Post Gain on Monday

Apple Stock Overcomes Trade Troubles to Post Gain on Monday

Economist Perspective: Can U.S. Dollar Keep Its Momentum in 2019?

Economist Perspective: Can U.S. Dollar Keep Its Momentum in 2019?

Stocks End Day in the Green as Dow, S&P Overcome Slow Starts

Stocks End Day in the Green as Dow, S&P Overcome Slow Starts