At least one group is getting fat off McDonald's (MCD) stock. 

McDonald's stock was hammered on Friday by 5% after prominent restaurant analyst David Palmer at RBC Capital Markets said consumer interest in the chain's new $1, $2, $3 value menu has been modest. The analyst slashed his price target on McDonald's stock to $170 from $190 and dropped his U.S. same-store sales estimate to an increase of 1% from 3.5%. 

The drop brought McDonald's stock down 13.8% so far this year, making it the second worst-performer on the Dow Jones Industrial Average behind the struggling General Electric (GE) (-19%).

Those short McDonald's have made a killing this year: $172.6 million in mark-to-market profits, according to S3 Analytics. The second most profitable short position in the restaurant space belongs to the under-performing Chipotle (CMG) , which has racked up $109 million in paper profits for the shorts.

The market may be overreacting on Mickey D's outlook for this year though. Another Wall Street firm believes McDonald's new $1, $2, $3 menu has greatly improved the perception of its value among consumers. 

"McDonald's is the value leader by a wide margin, with consumer 'good value' perceptions well above quick-service restaurant peers," UBS' research team wrote. "Fifty-two percent of consumers associated McDonald's with 'good value'' in our 2018 survey, a slight increase from 2016's survey."

The Golden Arches also received high consumer perceptions related to "good promotions" and "good selection of low-priced menu choices." Better value perception is often a good leading indicator on future sales trends for restaurants. 

Whatever one's view of McDonald's is right now, there is something to be agreed upon: the stock doesn't deserve to be mentioned in the same breath as General Electric

More from Opinion

Apple's iPhone XS and XS Max Are Good Enough to Win Over Owners of Older iPhones

Apple's iPhone XS and XS Max Are Good Enough to Win Over Owners of Older iPhones

Tuesday Turnaround: It's All About Microsoft...And Dogs?

Tuesday Turnaround: It's All About Microsoft...And Dogs?

Oracle Slumps After Missing Revenue Estimates: 7 Key Takeaways

Oracle Slumps After Missing Revenue Estimates: 7 Key Takeaways

Tesla Is Facing Tougher Model S and Model X Competition at an Inconvenient Time

Tesla Is Facing Tougher Model S and Model X Competition at an Inconvenient Time

Monday Madness: Lockheed Martin Takes to the Skies

Monday Madness: Lockheed Martin Takes to the Skies