SJM: Insiders vs. Shorts

The most recent short interest data was recently released for the 12/29/2017 settlement date, and J.M. Smucker Co. (SJM) is the #43 most shorted of the S&P 500 components, based on 9.45 "days to cover." There are a number of ways to look at short data, but one metric that we find particularly useful is the "days to cover" because it considers both the total shares short and the average daily volume of shares typically traded. The number of shares short is then divided by the average daily volume, to express the total number of trading days it would take to close out all of the open short positions if every share traded represented a short position being closed.

START SLIDESHOW:
Ten Bargains You Can Buy Cheaper Than The Insiders Did »

In the case of J.M. Smucker Co. ( SJM), the total short interest at the 12/29/2017 settlement date was 7,326,557 shares, which compares to the average daily trading volume of just 775,029 shares, for a "days to cover" ratio of 9.45.

When short sellers eventually cover their positions, by definition there must be buying activity because a share that is currently sold short must be purchased to be covered. At the present levels of short interest, if from this point forward every single SJM share traded represented a short position being closed, then at the average daily volume of 775,029 shares it would only be during the 10th trading day that every short position would be closed.

So it would stand to reason that should some unexpectedly good news come out, and short sellers did not have 10 days of patience but instead wanted to cover their short positions very suddenly, that situation could result in sending the stock higher until the higher price produces enough sellers to generate the necessary volume to close out those positions quickly.

J.M. Smucker Co. ( SJM) has something relatively rare for a stock with this much short interest, that being insiders taking the other side of the trade. Looking back over the trailing six month period, SJM has seen 2 different instances of insider buying, as summarized by the table below:

Purchased Insider Title Shares Price/Share Value
08/29/2017 Richard K. Smucker Executive Chairman 10,000 $105.40 $1,054,000.00
09/11/2017 Gary A. Oatey Director 1,000 $107.30 $107,297.00

Below is a chart showing the "days to cover" for SJM over time:

Loading+chart++2018+TickerTech.com

And looking at the chart below, SJM's low point in its 52 week range is $99.565 per share, with $143.68 as the 52 week high point — that compares with a last trade of $123.85.

J.M. Smucker Co. Moving Averages Chart

In recent trading, shares of J.M. Smucker Co. ( SJM) were changing hands at $123.85/share.

More from Stocks

Dow Dives on Earnings Disappointments From Caterpillar, 3M

Dow Dives on Earnings Disappointments From Caterpillar, 3M

Why Amazon Is One of Jim Cramer's 10 Best Stocks for a Market Pullback

Why Amazon Is One of Jim Cramer's 10 Best Stocks for a Market Pullback

Jim Cramer on What to Expect in the Market This Week

Jim Cramer on What to Expect in the Market This Week

Jim Cramer Previews Boeing and Mattel's Earnings

Jim Cramer Previews Boeing and Mattel's Earnings

Is Caterpillar Being Unfairly Singled Out in a Cyclical Sector?

Is Caterpillar Being Unfairly Singled Out in a Cyclical Sector?