By DAVID KLEPPERALBANY, N.Y. (AP) — Several power plant owners sued New York state energy regulators Wednesday over the state's approval of billions of dollars in subsidies for aging nuclear plants. The suit filed in Manhattan federal court argues the bailout represents an illegal interference with the federal government's role in regulating electric rates, and will unfairly burden the ratepayers who will pay for the subsidies, which could cost nearly $8 billion over 12 years. "This a bad deal for New Yorkers, who will see their electric bills go up across the state," said Jonathan Schiller, whose firm Boies, Schiller & Flexner is representing the plaintiffs, some of whom operate natural gas and coal-fired plants in the state. "This subsidy will cost New Yorkers as much as $7.6 billion in payments to a single company. This is illegal." The plaintiffs include Eastern Generation LLC, the Electric Power Supply Association, NRG Energy Inc., Roseton Generating LLC, Selkirk Cogen Partners L.P., Dynergy Inc., and the Coalition for Competitive Electricity. The state's Public Service Commission approved the investment in upstate nuclear plants earlier this year as part of a broader energy policy crafted by Democratic Gov. Andrew Cuomo. Cuomo argues that the investment in nuclear will allow the plants to remain open while the state reduces its use of fossil fuels and ramps up its reliance on renewable sources such as wind and solar. The cost of the subsidies is expected to total about $2 a month for average residential customers. Audrey Zibelman, chairwoman of the Public Service Commission, said the agency planned to "vigorously defend" the state's plan. "The frivolous lawsuit is right out of fossil fuel industry's playbook to deny and thwart actions to combat climate change," she said in a statement. While some environmental groups support the nuclear subsidies as a necessary part of reducing the use of coal and natural gas, other renewable energy advocates say they're an unnecessary investment in a potentially hazardous industry.
More from Opinion
Goldman Sachs: Should You Bet on Its Business Transformation?
Goldman Sachs is a higher-risk, higher-reward play that bargain hunters looking for a potentially successful business model transition story might want to consider.
PepsiCo: The Unlikely Growth Story Continues to Roll
Given the combination of solid execution, strong fundamentals and the diversification benefits of the stock, PepsiCo looks like a compelling buy following the company's strong third quarter earnings report.
There Will Be No Economic Collapse From a No-Deal Brexit
The EU can have Brexit and keep zero tariffs, which ought to be obvious.
Citigroup: Tread Carefully Around Bank Stocks Ahead of Earnings Season
Citigroup will probably have the robustness of global consumer activity to help it support financial results in the third quarter. But the current interest rate environment and a soft institutional services business pose significant challenges for the New York City-based mega bank.
Nike: When Playing Offense Makes Sense, Despite Softening Economy
Nike has been taking the right steps to ensure that it continues to thrive, regardless of the global economic landscape. Following the company's strong earnings report, an investment in the stock still makes sense.