More Than One-Third of Loan Co-Signers Have to Pay Up

It seemed like such an innocent request at the time. Your beloved daughter asks you to co-sign a loan for that new Toyota Prius.

You sign off on the co-sign, and six months later, your daughter has lost her job, can't make the loan payments, and there you go - it's up to you to make good on that loan debt.

This same scenario happens more than you may think. According to CreditCards.com, 38% of co-signers had to pay some or all of the bill, because the primary borrower did not. Furthermore, 28% saw a decline in their credit score because the main borrower paid late or not at all.

Being a loan co-signer can also lead to bruised feelings and battered relationships: 26% of co-signers interviewed in the CreditCards.com study say the loan experience "damaged" their relationship with the primary borrower.

As far as loan categories, auto loans accounted for 51% of all co-signings. Personal loans (24%), student loans (19%) and credit cards (16%) are also fairly common, the study reports. The odds are also best a child or step-child will be the one asking you to co-sign a loan.

"With a 38% chance of losing money and a 26% chance of damaging a relationship, co-signing doesn't sound like a very good bet," says Matt Schulz, CreditCards.com's senior industry analyst. "If you absolutely have to co-sign, then at least be aware there's a sizable chance you'll lose some money and/or get your feelings hurt."

So what does it really mean to be a loan co-signer? Straight to the chase, it means taking a risk with your cash and your credit.

"The risks of co-signing a loan can be varied and many, but at minimum it will mean that you are responsible for the debt in the event the primary debtor doesn't repay," says Amos Richards, CEO of Fundist.com, a small business financial funding firm.

"This can mean liens against your assets, and even garnishment of paychecks," he adds. "A loan is a contract - so that's going to be your primary resource as to what's possible."

Ask most loan industry insiders if they would ever co-sign for a loan, and you'll get a direct response.

"Even if it was my son, I would never do it in a million years," says Robert Pellegrini, president of the law firm PK Boston and a Massachusetts real estate attorney. "I worked hard for this credit."

Typically a co-signed contract is between a parent and a child, Pellegrini says. "Many people don't realize that co-signing a contract impacts your available amount of credit and may no longer be available to you," he adds. "You could very well be declined, even if you have good credit, if you don't have enough income to justify the loans."

David Hryck, a New York City tax lawyer and personal finance expert notes you can also face hefty tax costs when a co-signed loan goes south.

"When you co-sign a loan you can face tax consequences if the debt is settled," says Hryck. "In many cases, the lender may decide that they'll bypass legal action and will decide to settle the balance owed. In such a case, you're now tax liable for the difference. For example, if you owe $5,000 and settle at $3,000 you would potentially have to report the remaining balance as a 'debt forgiveness income' when you file your end of year tax forms."

There are other ways to help out a friend or a family member looking for credit, other experts say.

"If the person can't get a loan in the first place that's a red flag," says Scott Vance, a financial advisor with Trisuli Financial Advising. "I advise my clients that if they truly intend on helping the person seeking the co-signer, consider just buying the item outright or contributing enough for them to become eligible for the loan and consider it a gift."

Note also that most student loans do not require co-signers. "Federal student loans, such as the Federal Stafford loan and Federal Perkins loan, do not require co-signers," says Mark Kantrowitz, publisher and vice president of strategy at Cappex.com, a company that connects students with colleges and financial aid. "Private student loans, on the other hand, almost always require a co-signer. More than 90% of private student loans to undergraduate students require co-signers and more than 75% of private student loans to graduate and professional students require co-signers."

Parents should ask themselves how much they trust their child before co-signing a private student loan for the child, Kantrowitz. "Co-signing a private student loan is like giving the student control over the parent's finances, since an irresponsible or careless student can easily ruin the parent's credit," he says.

The operative message for anyone asked to co-sign a loan is to tread cautiously, and exhaust all possible options before signing on the bottom line.

Your financial health, and your relationship with a loved one, may depend on it.

If you liked this article you might like

Telematics Could Cut Your Car Insurance, but There Are Privacy Risks

Telematics Could Cut Your Car Insurance, but There Are Privacy Risks

Using Twitter to Trade Stocks

Using Twitter to Trade Stocks

Is Your Robo-Adviser Really a Robot?

Is Your Robo-Adviser Really a Robot?

My Stepmother Stole My Inheritance

My Stepmother Stole My Inheritance

Celebrating Valentine's Day at a Heart-Happy Price

Celebrating Valentine's Day at a Heart-Happy Price