The for-profit company, citing data from the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, says the average premium for an individual plan before subsidies were applied was $346 per month (shrinking to an average $82 per month with the subsidies) but for people buying without subsidies an individual plan was $271 per month.
Among shoppers with subsidies, "silver" plans were the most common, but for among unsubsidized shoppers "bronze" plans were the most common, the company says. Subsidized shoppers felt like they had $75 more to spend per month.
Under the Bronze plan, deductibles can be higher, so bronze buyers who were also forced to use their insurance to the hilt could pay more than $4,000 annually. The difference suggests economists will get their test of a long-held belief: that Americans would be wiser consumers of health care when faced with its actual costs.
Read More: 5 Approaches to Health That Will Hurt You
With Obamacare adding some 8 million to 10 million Americans to the rolls of those insured, half of Americans said they were spending more on health care and half reported spending less, according to Bankrate.com. Another 46% of Americans say much higher prices for health plans could be a major problem during the upcoming enrollment season, although rates have only begun to be rolled out and insurers are so far announcing a range of decreases and increases.