Target-Date Funds Are No Bargains, Study Says

BOSTON (TheStreet) -- Investors may be losing as much as $1.3 billion a year because of target-date funds' underperforming investments and fees, according to a study by Georgia State University.

Conflicts of interest can arise when fund managers turn to their own companies' mutual funds for employee retirement plans. Target-date funds tend to select high-fee and underperforming funds, resulting in the worst-case scenario seen in research by Vallapuzha Sandhya, a doctoral student of finance at Georgia's J. Mack Robinson College of Business, data from 2003 to 2008 show.

With target-date funds, investors choose a retirement year and let the fund automatically adjust a portfolio's exposure to stocks and bonds over time. Younger investors will likely have more aggressive portfolios, with upward of 90% devoted to stocks. In theory, the portfolios become more conservative as participants age. Target-date funds are typically made up of other stocks and bond mutual funds.

There's an alternative that deserves greater consideration, Sandhya says: "Balanced funds" that can do the job as well, if not better, by mixing stocks and bonds. Unlike target-date funds, balanced funds maintain their allocations, rather than adjusting for risk profile or market conditions. Popular examples include Vanguard Group's Vanguard Wellington (VWELX) , T. Rowe Price's (TROW) T. Rowe Price Personal Strategy Balanced (TRPBX) and Wells Fargo's (WFC) Wells Fargo Advantage WealthBuilder Growth Balanced (WBGBX) .

But traditional target-date funds remain attractive. Assets in target-date funds have skyrocketed from just under $2 billion in 1997 to $270 billion last month, according to the Securities and Exchange Commission.

(VWELX) (TROW) (TRPBX) (WFC) (WBGBX) Increased popularity, however, wasn't matched by improved oversight.


If you liked this article you might like

10 Forces Conspiring Against Your Savings

10 Worst-Off State Pension Funds

10 Ways Your 401(k) Can Fail You

A Spy Kit for the Modern James Bond

Prep Your Portfolio for Disaster With a Stress Test