A home equity loan can be a lifesaver, used to pay down high-interest credit card bills, put a child through college, pay for home expansion or help the homeowner weather a financial rough spot.
But it’s not a move to be taken lightly. Saddling your home with a second loan could prevent you from using a last-ditch exit strategy in a financial crisis — turning your home over to the lender with minimal consequences to your credit rating.
A growing number of mortgage lenders are offering “deeds in lieu of foreclosure,” an easy way out for borrowers behind in payments. Instead of going through the torturous foreclosure process you could simply hand over the keys. In many cases, the lender will allow the homeowner to remain in the property briefly, or to rent it at a market rate. Some lenders even provide a modest sum to help the homeowner relocate.
A deed in lieu of foreclosure is a black mark on your credit history, but may not be as bad as a standard foreclosure. Experts say the homeowner should try to negotiate with the lender over how the event will be reported to credit agencies.
The best option is “paid as agreed,” followed by “paid settlement” then “foreclosure.” With a “paid as agreed” report, you’d be eligible for a Fannie Mae mortgage in four years after giving up your home, while it would take five years after a foreclosure. With extenuating circumstances, such as a job loss or major medical problem, the Fannie Mae waiting period could be as short as two years after a deed in lieu of foreclosure, three years after a foreclosure.
There’s no way to force the lender to agree to a deed in lieu of foreclosure, and it may be difficult if you owe more than the property is worth. But it is an option worth exploring. It’s less of a hassle than a short sale, in which a home is sold for less than is owed, with the lender agreeing to settle the debt so long as a minimum price is received. A deed in lieu of foreclosure allows the lender to get the home on the market faster than in a foreclosure, so lenders have an incentive to consider it.