What Drives Investors to Tata? Tesla's Valuation

NEW YORK (TheStreet) -- The U.S. stock market is in a lull.  When I look at the 3,800 or so companies in my Best Stocks Now! universe there have not been a lot of big winners thus far this year.

But when I look beyond the U.S. to the emerging markets, I see some opportunities -- particularly in India where Tata Motors (TTM) is based.

The U.S. market malaise has been partly caused by an outsized gain in the market in 2013 and market valuations that got ahead of themselves. As a result, there has been a flight to safety this year and a greater focus on valuation, favoring value stocks over growth names.

Since the U.S. economy is not on fire, I seek better opportunities elsewhere.

I like is Brazil and own the MSCI Brazil Index Fund (EWZ) exchange-traded fund. Brazil used to be darling of emerging market investors but recent high inflation has crippled the Brazilian consumer. The pro-business party is now leading in the polls and the Brazilian market has rallied 31% since it bottomed in early February.

India is another country benefiting from political reform. Just last week, the pro-business candidate Narendra Modi won in the election. I am looking to add to my India exposure, which is why I think Tata Motors is attractive.

I said "ta-ta" to another automaker, Tesla (TSLA) a few months back. I am still a big believer in the Elon Musk story and the companies where he invests including Tesla, SolarCity (SCTY), and SpaceX. But this is quite simply not a favorable market environment for high-valuation stocks.

Comparing Tesla side by side with Tata -- both auto companies have a market capitalization of around $25 billion. But this is a market that favors value stocks. Year-to-date performance is similar but since March Tesla stock has been on the decline while Tata's performance has been steadily on the rise.

TSLA Chart
TSLA
data by YCharts

Telsa is currently trading at 62X forward earnings. Tata Motors, on the other hand, has a low forward PE of only 9X and it is part of an India economy that may be poised to grow at a higher rate than the U.S. economy. Despite its low PE, Tata is expected to grow at 25% rate over the next five years vs Tesla at 40%. Is that marginally better growth rate really worth the disparity in valuation?

Tata is ranked #82 in the Gunderson stock universe, while Tesla is ranked #1,851. So in the current market environment, it is time to say "ta-ta" to Tesla.

At the time of publication the author was long TTM.

>>Read more: headline

This article represents the opinion of a contributor and not necessarily that of TheStreet or its editorial staff.

>>Read more: Russia and China Sign Mega Gas Deal That Changes Everything

More from Emerging Markets

China's Gear Shift on Auto Tariffs Moves Industry in an Unusual Direction

China's Gear Shift on Auto Tariffs Moves Industry in an Unusual Direction

Closed-End Funds Stage Modest Comeback

Closed-End Funds Stage Modest Comeback

Studying Up on Arco Platform for a Potential Trade

Studying Up on Arco Platform for a Potential Trade

December's Climate Forecast: Stormy Winter Markets

December's Climate Forecast: Stormy Winter Markets

The Most Valuable Nation Brands of 2018

The Most Valuable Nation Brands of 2018