Why J.C. Penney's Turnaround Still Isn't 'Good Enough'

This story has been updated from May 14, 2014 to include BMO Capital Markets analyst commentary.

NEW YORK (TheStreet) - J.C. Penney (JCP) reports first-quarter earnings after the markets close on Thursday, and the April-ending quarter will be a big test to see if the struggling retailer is ready to set its sights past a turnaround and onto how to will achieve and maintain a profitable future.

Current management has been working hard to reverse J.C. Penney's ill fortune of a failed attempt to overhaul of the Plano, Texas-based department store's strategy under its former CEO, Ron Johnson. J.C. Penney's current CEO Myron 'Mike' Ullman said in a fourth-quarter earnings call that the company planned to complete the turnaround by the end of this year.

The first quarter will finally be a period in which J.C. Penney's sales and margin numbers will give investors a true look into the company's performance, now that underperforming merchandise brands that didn't resonate with customers have been mostly removed and popular private-label brands have been restocked. But it's been a tough road to pull up comparable sales, even in the all-important holiday quarter, comps only rose 2% over the prior year's quarter. Will J.C. Penney's first quarter's earnings be more of the same disappointment, hampered even further by a rough winter that affected all retail sales?

The harsh winter took a toll on sales at retail bellwether Macy's (M). The department store chain kicked off retail earnings reports on Wednesday by reporting first-quarter profit of 60 cents a share, compared to consensus estimates of 59 cents a share, according to Thomson Reuters.

However Macy's sales fell 1.7% as compared to the prior quarter, to $6.279 billion, and fell short of analysts' expectations of $6.457 billion for the quarter. Macy's reported comparable store sales fell 1.6% for the quarter compared to estimates of 0.7% growth. Comps including sales from departments licensed to third parties declined 0.8% in the quarter as compared to the year-earlier period.

Macy's reiterated its guidance for comp growth in fiscal 2014 in the range of 2.5% to 3%. The company also reiterated its guidance for 2014 earnings of $4.40 to $4.50 a share.

In contrast, expectations for J.C. Penney are already incredibly low for the quarter. Analysts are expecting a loss of $1.25 a share for the company's fiscal first quarter versus $1.38 a share loss in the first quarter of 2013, according to a survey from Thomson Reuters.

J.C. Penney's revenue is expected to rise 3% from last year's quarter to $2.707 billion, according to Thomson Reuters. That's pitiful though when compared to Amazon's (AMZN) most recent quarterly net sales, which increased 23% to $19.74 billion.

That said, J.C. Penney shares have surged 44% since its last earnings report on February 26. "We believe the turnaround is still on track," writes Piper Jaffray analyst Neely Tamminga in a note to clients last week.

Tamminga, who has an "overweight" rating on the stock, based her conclusion on several factors. According to Tamminga, customers are liking what they see at J.C. Penney stores; the completed changeover in the home category; J.C. Penney's improved inventory management and product balance as well as private-label brands being restored, boding well for margins.

Additionally, J.C. Penney has returned to a commission-based sales associate in key categories that will help sales growth in key categories. Finally, the company has a lot of potential in online sales and mobile-driven commerce, Tamminga writes.

However, David Tawil, co-founder and portfolio manager at Maglan Capital, a hedge fund that focuses on distressed companies, is not optimistic about J.C. Penney's future. "We view the turnaround as challenging with a high level of execution difficulty," he wrote in an email to TheStreet. Maglan is not currently invested in or short J.C. Penney's stock. Maglan Capital has $70 million in assets under management.

"Clearly at this point, they are not looking it seems for a [long term] CEO," Tawil speculated in a follow-up interview, referring to the fact that Ullman was re-hired to his old position on an interim basis. "It sounds like they've called off the search there."

Tawil notes recent press reports pointing out the dearth of qualified CEOs that can come in and recreate struggling retailers (Target (TGT) and American Eagle Outfitters (AEO) are also on the hunt for new chief executives) doesn't bode well for J.C. Penney. Especially as the retail sector undergoes a radical shift away from stores as destinations and more towards e-commerce and mobile opportunities.

While Ullman may be "good enough" to reverse the failings of former CEO Ron Johnson, "if I'm an investor, I'm looking for growth," Tawil stated. "The status quo is just not good enough from an investor point of view."

"I just don't think that there is anyone that could go ahead and revitalize this company. As an investor that leaves me with a great deal of pause," he noted.

Retail sales rose a paltry 0.1% for the month of April, below consensus expectations of 0.4% gain and far below the 1.5% improvement in March.  That's likely to not bode well for J.C. Penney, which forecast same-store sales comp growth between 3% and 5% for the quarter compared to falling 16.6% in the first quarter of 2013. Analysts on average expect comps to rise 4% over last year's quarter.

"As for the sequential comp trend, we hold a below consensus stance at 2.0% and believe that following January's down 3.5%: February improved, but was still running negative, March deteriorated given poor weather/the Easter shift, and April improved significantly, but likely not enough to reach guided levels," penned Sterne Agee analyst Charles Grom in a research note. Grom rates J.C. Penney at "neutral."

"We sense the buy-side is anticipating a comp of +4.0%-5.0% following last year's down 17.7% print, which was heavily influenced (~300 bps) by the closing of Penney's home category in ~500 doors. Importantly, a potentially strong Easter selling season (per our own store checks and lateral reads from GPS, ZUMZ, and LB) and momentum into Mother's Day could give the bulls something to hang their hats on," the Sterne Agee note stated.

Sales aside, J.C. Penney's other big test is gross margin levels which should receive a boost from fewer discounted merchandise items J.C. Penney has cleared out.

"After clearing most of the merchandise brought-in by prior [management] to restock with JCP legacy brands, levels of deep discounting should subside" in the first and second quarters, UBS analyst Michael Binetti writes in a May 7 note in which he upgraded the stock to "neutral" from "sell." "We see less risk of substantial SSS/GM misses lapping these one-time disruptions." Binetti expects comps to rise 4% in the first quarter as well as the second quarter. He's also forecasting gross margin improvement of 450 basis points and 400 basis points, in the same time periods compared to prior year quarters.

"The next stock test will be whether JCP can continue to show significant/profitable SSS increases in 2H14 as the benefits of lapping one-time disruptions from 1H13 diminish," Binetti writes. "As these tailwinds abate and SSS compares begin to normalize (SSS compares are -14% in 1H, and only -1% in 2H), we believe investors will increasingly scrutinize current valuation (which we believe assigns a premium to the reasonable LT EBITDA potential for JCP today) if it becomes clear that JCP can't meaningfully outpace broader department store industry SSS averages over several years."

BMO Capital Markets analyst Wayne Hood rates J.C. Penney at "underperform" over concerns that the company could do another dilutive capital raise later this year or early 2015.

"Looking toward 2Q14, we look for the company to build on the rollout of the new home offering, growing comp-store sales about 5% on top of the projected 4% growth in 1Q14. We look for management to give an update on two important initiatives: 1) the rollout of the home offering and the impact store traffic and its halo effect on the rest of the store; and 2) the effect the reintroduction of key basic items and popular brands to the company's assortment late in FY2013 has had on both the company's traffic and average ticket," Hood writes in a May 9 note to clients.

--Written by Laurie Kulikowski in New York.

>>Read More:

Mobile Commerce Expected to Surpass $100B in 2014. But Are Retailers Ready?

Why Netflix Will Cost More Now

5 Free Wedding Apps for Every Bride (and Groom)


Disclosure: TheStreet's editorial policy prohibits staff editors, reporters and analysts from holding positions in any individual stocks.

More from Stocks

A Thunderous Herd of Scared Baby Boomer Investors Could Crush the Market

A Thunderous Herd of Scared Baby Boomer Investors Could Crush the Market

With GE Dropped From the Dow, Be Selective About Industrials Stocks

With GE Dropped From the Dow, Be Selective About Industrials Stocks

Dow Rises as Blue-Chip Index Looks to End Losing Streak

Dow Rises as Blue-Chip Index Looks to End Losing Streak

3 Ways to Fix Starbucks Biggest Challenges

3 Ways to Fix Starbucks Biggest Challenges

General Electric's Boot From the Dow: Is This as Bad as It Can Get?

General Electric's Boot From the Dow: Is This as Bad as It Can Get?