The Return Of Energy ETF Dominance?

NEW YORK (ETF Expert) -- Energy exchange-traded funds outperformed the overwhelming majority of competing sector investments in the previous bull market from October 2002 to October 2007.

In the early part of the run, the war in Iraq boosted the demand for shares. In the later stages of the rally, emerging economic growth fueled speculative excesses in both the price of oil as well as desire for ownership in exploration and/or oil services companies.

The last three years, however, have been remarkably unkind to energy stocks. Whereas the S&P 500 has rocketed skyward, the SPDR Select Sector Energy Fund (XLE) annualized at approximately 5.6%. In contrast, SPDR Select Sector Consumer Discretionary (XLY) and SPDR Select Sector Health Care (XLV) logged three-year annualized gains of 20.2% and 23.2%, respectively.

XLE Comparison

In hindsight, one can tether the damage to the energy patch to woes across the emerging economy board. Both China and Brazil have seen significant declines in their domestic outputs. India has battled severe inflation. And Russia? Whether it is a military engagement with Ukraine or a dependence on its natural resources exports, investors have historically shown an aversion to paying much for shares in Russian corporations.

It follows that a three-year bearish period for emerging markets -- a period where iShares Emerging Markets (EEM) has floundered -- corresponds to the relative weakness in U.S. energy stock investing.

EEM 3 Years

Perhaps surprisingly, the prior three months have painted a different portrait of the global investing landscape. Vanguard Total Stock Market (VTI) has straddled the flatline. PowerShares Nasdaq 100 (QQQ) has lost ground. In contrast, XLE and EEM are gaining heads of steam.

XLE Comparison Over 3 Months

What may be most telling? The most visible members on the 52-week new high list below relate to the energy complex. You will not find XLY or there. Nor will you find broader market benchmarks covering the U.S., Europe or the Far East. Yet, you will find assets tied to natural gas, energy infrastructure, oil equipment, "fracking" and energy production.

Changing Of the Guard? Energy-Related ETFs Hitting New 52-Week Highs
             
            Approx 3 Months
             
First Trust Natural Gas (FCG)       15.8%
SPDR Energy and Exploration (XOP)     15.5%
Market Vectors Unconventional Oil & Gas (FRAK)   14.4%
iShares DJ Oil Equipment & Services (IEZ)   10.3%
Vanguard Energy (VDE)       8.4%
             
Vanguard Total Stock Market (VTI)     1.0%
             

In truth, if emerging market stocks falter yet again, U.S. energy stocks may not reassert themselves as much as one might hope. There is a relationship between U.S. energy company shares and foreign markets. That said, some have estimated a 40% P/E discount for emergers when comparing against the P/E "price tag" being paid to own broad U.S. exposure.

"Global value" might act as a buffer against dramatic deterioration abroad. It may also give the energy sector a leg up in the months and years ahead.

This article represents the opinion of a contributor and not necessarily that of TheStreet or its editorial staff.

More from Emerging Markets

Wall Street Looks To Extends Gains After Goldman Earnings Beat, China Data

Wall Street Looks To Extends Gains After Goldman Earnings Beat, China Data

China's President Xi Jinping Tells Boao Forum He Supports Opening Markets

China's President Xi Jinping Tells Boao Forum He Supports Opening Markets

U.S. Stock Futures Steady; Asia Stocks Mostly Lower

U.S. Stock Futures Steady; Asia Stocks Mostly Lower

Jim Cramer: There Are Plenty of Shorts in Constellation Brands

Jim Cramer: There Are Plenty of Shorts in Constellation Brands

Renault Shares Hit 10-Year High on Nissan Merger Report

Renault Shares Hit 10-Year High on Nissan Merger Report