Seymour disagreed, bearishly arguing Netflix faces usage-based pricing headwinds as well as rising content costs. He added that competition in streaming video and original content is increasing while second-quarter guidance may be weaker than investors are anticipating.
Both Adami and Kelly believed that Netflix was headed higher following its earnings report.
Barnes & Noble (BKS) fell 12%, making it the first stock on the show's "Pops & Drops" segment. Adami was not a buyer at current levels.
Schlumberger (SLB) dropped 1%. Seymour said to stay long but not to buy at current levels.
GoGo (GOGO) jumped 6%. Nathan said the stock is overbought and investors can buy near current levels.
SanDisk (SNDK) popped 9%. Kelly suggested that investors buy the stock, but only after a pullback
Nathan said Occidental Petroleum (OXY) seems poised to break out to the upside. He cited bullish options activity as well.
In honor of CNBC's 25th anniversary, the traders gave their top picks for the next 25 years. Seymour was a buyer of General Electric and Nathan said to buy Amazon (AMZN). Adami was a buyer of Honeywell International (HON) and Kelly said to buy Bitcoin.
-- Written by Bret Kenwell in Petoskey, Mich.