The New #59 Most Shorted S&P 500 Component: Carmax

The most recent short interest data has been released by the NASDAQ for the 03/31/2014 settlement date, and we here at Dividend Channel like to sift through this fresh data and order the underlying components of the S&P 500 by "days to cover." There are a number of ways to look at short data, for example the total number of shares short; but one metric that we find particularly useful is the "days to cover" metric because it considers both the total shares short and the average daily volume of shares typically traded. The number of shares short is then compared to the average daily volume, in order to calculate the total number of trading days it would take to close out all of the open short positions if every share traded represented a short position being closed.

START SLIDESHOW:
Top 25 S.A.F.E. Dividend Stocks »

In our new rank based on the most recent short interest data from NASDAQ, Carmax Inc. ( KMX) has taken over the position of #59 most shorted S&P 500 component, from Gilead Sciences, Inc. ( GILD) which is now in the #140 spot. The "days to cover" at 03/31/2014 was 7.10 for KMX, and 4.71 for GILD; this compares to the average across all S&P 500 components of 3.92 (down from the average back on the 03/14/2014 settlement date of 4.09). The chart below shows the movement over time of the "days to cover" values of both KMX and GILD, versus the average S&P 500 component.

Loading+chart++2014+TickerTech.com

Below is a chart showing the relative positions of KMX versus GILD over time within the 500 S&P 500 components, with #1 representing the component with the highest "days to cover" value (most heavily shorted) and #500 representing the component with the lowest "days to cover" value (least heavily shorted):

Loading+chart++2014+TickerTech.com

A stock with a high "days to cover" value compared to its peers would be considered to have a higher level of short interest as compared to those peers. This could mean short sellers are using the stock to hedge a long bet elsewhere, or could also mean that short sellers believe the price of the stock will decline. When short sellers eventually cover their positions, by definition there must be buying activity because a share that is currently sold short must be purchased to be covered. So investors tend to keep an eye on that "days to cover" metric, because a high value could predict a sharper price increase should the company put out some unexpectedly good news — short sellers might rush to cover positions, and if the "days to cover" number is high, it is more difficult to close those positions without sending the stock higher until the higher price produces enough sellers to generate the necessary volume.

Below is a three month price history chart comparing the stock performance of KMX vs. GILD:

KMX,GILD Relative Performance Chart

According to the ETF Finder at ETF Channel, KMX and GILD collectively make up 1.79% of the iShares MSCI KLD 400 Social ETF (DSI) which is lower by about 1.5% on the day Thursday.

At last check, KMX was down about 2.4%, while GILD was off about 6.9% on the day Thursday.

More from Stocks

Global Stocks Rally as US-China Trade War Thaws; Dow Could Test 25,000

Global Stocks Rally as US-China Trade War Thaws; Dow Could Test 25,000

China Trade Truce, General Electric and Tesla - 5 Things You Must Know

China Trade Truce, General Electric and Tesla - 5 Things You Must Know

The Stock Market Has Every Reason to See a Fresh Rally

The Stock Market Has Every Reason to See a Fresh Rally

18 Top Stocks Hedge Funds Own That Goldman Sachs Thinks Will Keep Outperforming

18 Top Stocks Hedge Funds Own That Goldman Sachs Thinks Will Keep Outperforming

3 Simple Tips on Investing From TheStreet's Jim Cramer

3 Simple Tips on Investing From TheStreet's Jim Cramer