Should You Believe the HP Hype?

NEW YORK ( TheStreet) -- Back in December, I wrote an article highlighting the deficits Hewlett-Packard ( HPQ) still faced, even amidst the stock's revival. Investors had gotten ahead of themselves.

Since then, HP stock has climbed another 13%. Some are using this opportunity to take their shots -- and I don't have a problem with that. HP has made some meaningful strides over the past couple of months.

But I'm not ready to back away from my assessment. HP is overhyped.

HP's core business remains in decay. And despite the optimism of CEO Meg Whitman regarding personal computers, PCs are no longer a growth industry. In the markets that do matter, like tablets and smartphones, HP does not have a product to sell. So what's all the commotion about?

Was the stock too cheap several quarters ago? An argument can be made that it was. Plus, the embarrassment and scandal surrounding the botched deal for Autonomy certainly didn't help. So the stock had been punished for various reasons, not all of which aligned with HP's fundamental value.

At best, HP shares have been correcting upward. In terms of real growth, HP has produced very little to support the stock's 50% gains in the trailing 12 months. This is a distinction that needs to be made. Let's be honest with ourselves. How much longer are we going to cheer "less bad" results?

For instance, in the recent quarter, revenue was down 1% year over year. The Street applauded the fact that this was higher than estimates. Given how bad the year-ago quarter was, there was a low bar set. Plus, there's no question too much was made of the 4% increase in the PC division. Who's buying them?

Likewise, this notion that PC sales for major vendors have bottomed is grossly premature. According to data by research group Gartner, PC sales are still on the decline. And even if we were to assume a bottom has been reached, what sort of track record have we seen to believe HP is better positioned than Lenovo (LNVGY) to secure the market?

Let's not forget, although Dell may have gone private, the company is still a dominant enterprise power. Along those lines, Apple (AAPL) has begun to grow incremental share. And then there's Google (GOOG). Chromebooks were once considered just for play, but Google has put a strong marketing plan behind these devices, suggesting that Google itself is not playing around.

HP, on the other hand, had remained steadfast about not wanting to sacrifice margins in PCs to compete on price. But the company's hand has been forced. Some lower price points helped with the recent sales volume.

The question you should be asking is this: amid price cuts, how did HP generate $3 billion free cash flow for the quarter?

If you liked this article you might like

Why This Former Tech CEO Thinks One of the Biggest Business Risks Is Fear

Hewlett Packard Enterprise Becomes the Latest Tech Titan to Slash Jobs

Microsoft's New Xbox One X Shows It's Done Trying to Please Everyone

Hewlett Packard Enterprise's Meg Whitman Joins Dropbox

Carly Fiorina Will Not Run for Senate in 2018