Foreign Developed ETFs vs. Domestic Stock ETFs

NEW YORK (ETF Expert) -- Investors who allocated a portion of their capital abroad have been experiencing a whole lot of performance envy lately.

For instance, those who concentrated their dollars in the S&P 500 last year savored 30% price appreciation, while those who allocated some money to the MSCI EAFE Index struggled to come to terms with a disappointing 18%. Heaven forbid you believed that emerging market valuations were so cheap that you had placed a small stake in the MSCI Emerging Market Index; exchange-traded funds tracking the index actually lost value in 2013.

Perhaps unfortunately, U.S. Federal Reserve "tapering" is liable to increase borrowing costs and dent currencies in developing countries. Couple the reduction in electronic dollar printing with an exodus of capital from up-n-coming regions, and the prospect for a turnaround in Vanguard Emerging Markets (VWO) appears to be a crisis or two away. Worse yet, the technical deterioration associated with the dreaded "black cross" - the 50-day moving average crossing below its 200-day moving average - is likely to coincide with additional downside in price.

Not everything is as gloomy abroad as it seems at first blush, however. A flash eurozone manufacturing indicator in January jumped to its highest level in two-and-a-half years (53.9). What's more, whereas the U.S. central bank (i.e., Federal Reserve) feels pressure to taper (a.k.a. "tighten") or maintain its current level of monetary accommodation, the European Central Bank actually has room to loosen its policy to support investor sentiment as well as boost economic growth. With price-to-earnings ratios in the U.S. at lofty levels by most traditional measures, the eurozone has been looking better.

This is not to suggest that Europe is without risk. On the contrary: The entire continent has plenty of walls of worry to climb. Nevertheless, it is worth noting the month-over-month differences between key foreign developed stock ETFs and U.S. stock ETFs. Might the percentages represent a January barometer of relative strength?

Performance Shift Overseas?        
            1 Month %
             
iShares MSCI Small Cap EAFE (SCZ)     0.4%
Vanguard Europe (VGK)       -1.0%
iShares MSCI European Monetary Union (EZU)   -1.2%
iShares MSCI EAFE Index (EFA)       -1.7%
WisdomTree Hedged Europe (HEDJ)     -2.0%
             
S&P 500 SPDR Trust (SPY)       -2.6%
Dow Jones Industrials (DIA)       -3.2%
             

According to Russ Koesterich at BlackRock (BLK), there have been 14 calendar years since 1954 when interest rates and P/E ratios both rose in the U.S. The average return in the following year for the S&P 500? Just 2.3%. Raising some cash to buy U.S. stocks on a significant selloff may have a greater probability of success on the domestic front than holding-n-hoping throughout 2014.

If you liked this article you might like

4 ETFs to Profit From an Uncertain Political Environment

4 Outperforming ETFs to Own Right Now

With Emerging Markets Up, Is China the Best Landing Spot for ETF Investing?

6 Months Later, It's a Whole New Ballgame

6 Months Later, It's a Whole New Ballgame

Ray Dalio's Biggest Hedge Fund Hits the Pain Button