CommonWealth REIT Files Definitive Consent Revocation Materials

CommonWealth REIT (NYSE: CWH) (“CWH” or the “Company”) today announced that it has filed definitive consent revocation materials with the Securities and Exchange Commission (the “SEC”) in connection with the consent solicitation initiated by Related Fund Management, LLC and Corvex Management LP (“Related/Corvex”) to remove the entire CWH Board of Trustees without cause.

CWH is disappointed that Related/Corvex have ignored CWH’s offers to settle by adding Keith Meister of Corvex to the Company's Board of Trustees, and instead Related/Corvex have decided to move forward with a written consent solicitation to remove the entire existing Board without cause. Mr. Meister's participation on the Board would allow him to work collaboratively with other Board members to create value for all shareholders and would allow shareholders to avoid the disruption and expense caused by moving forward with a contested consent solicitation.

CWH recommends that shareholders disregard any Related/Corvex consent solicitation materials they may receive and protect their investment in CWH by signing, dating and returning the Company’s WHITE consent revocation card, which they will soon receive by mail.

The definitive consent revocation materials being mailed to shareholders include the following letter:


Please sign, date and return the enclosed WHITE CONSENT REVOCATION CARD today!

Please DO NOT sign or return any materials sent to you by Related/Corvex to facilitate their attempt to take control of CommonWealth without paying you a premium.

We understand that you may have received or soon will receive materials from Related Fund Management, LLC (“Related”), Corvex Management LP (“Corvex”) and certain of their affiliates (collectively, “Related/Corvex”) seeking your written consent to remove, without cause, the entire Board of Trustees (the “Board”) of CommonWealth REIT (the “Company”). We believe this is yet another attempt by Related, with the assistance of Corvex, to take control of the Company for their own benefit without paying you any control premium.

We believe the Related/Corvex effort to remove the entire Board without cause is a disruptive and value destructive exercise. The Board and the Company’s management team are focused on delivering value to all shareholders. We believe that Related/Corvex are pursuing their own agenda and will not act in your best interests.

Your Board has evaluated the limited information that Related/Corvex have made available about their plan for the Company and concluded that it is not in the Company's or our shareholders’ best interests. Since Related/Corvex first approached the Company, the Board has worked diligently to understand the views of all of our shareholders, advanced the Company’s value-enhancing business plan and made meaningful governance and management compensation changes directly in response to shareholder suggestions.

Under the current Board and management team, the Company continues to make significant progress in the implementation of its business plan to reposition the Company’s portfolio towards higher quality central business district office properties in order to increase shareholder value.

During 2013, the Board and management:
  • improved the Company’s balance sheet;
  • continued to implement the Company’s business plan to reposition our portfolio into higher value office properties in central business district (“CBD”) locations and sell non-core industrial and suburban properties, which we believe will increase value for all shareholders in the future;
  • implemented changes to our business management agreement to further align management’s financial incentives with returns realized by shareholders; and
  • announced many governance enhancements.

Related/Corvex claim to be champions of good governance, yet they failed to disclose to CommonWealth shareholders that their claims regarding the financial benefits of removing the Board are based on unrealistic financial projections.

Related/Corvex told shareholders they estimated that, “after removal of current trustees,” the Company’s net operating income would increase by almost $70 million annually within just 18 months and the Company’s net asset value would be $35 per Common Share, with a target price of $44 per Common Share or higher by the end of 2014. Related/Corvex neglected to disclose that their estimates and targets would be unlikely, if not impossible, to achieve, without unrealistic increases in our revenues and decreases in our expenses. Related/Corvex publicly announced and distributed their projections, estimates and targets without any accompanying disclosure of the material assumptions underlying them and the limitations of those assumptions. We believe Related/Corvex failed to provide this information to you because they did not want to subject their assumptions to independent review.

Consistent with their investment mandate, Related and its trustee nominees may seek to run the Company like a distressed real estate fund, not a stable portfolio of high-quality Class A, CBD assets. Related’s Common Shares are held through its affiliate, Related Real Estate Recovery Fund, L.P., a fund that Related has publicly described as a “distressed real estate fund” which aims to invest in “properties that require significant repositioning.” Based on this investment mandate, and Related/Corvex’s previous investor presentations, we believe Related’s business plan for the Company contemplates: (1) the sale of some of our best performing Class A, CBD assets that produce stable returns for our investors; and (2) significant investment in underperforming properties that we have designated as discontinued operations and believe to be riskier investments. In our view, this plan would fundamentally change the Company’s risk profile and adversely impact the Company’s ability to pay dividends.

The Board recently announced the restructuring of our business management agreement with our manager and significant governance changes that directly address shareholder feedback.

In response to shareholder suggestions, the Board is making meaningful governance changes, including:
  • adding additional Independent Trustees;
  • appointing a Lead Independent Trustee;
  • declassifying the Board; and
  • streamlining the shareholder Trustee nomination and proposal process for our annual meetings, including our meeting this June.

The Board has also recently restructured the compensation payable to our manager to further align management’s financial incentives with the returns realized by our shareholders.

Related/Corvex are asking you to remove experienced Trustees who are acting in the best interest of the Company and its shareholders.

The current Board includes new members who provide fresh perspectives as well as longer serving Trustees with significant experience managing the Company and a unique knowledge of our portfolio, our tenants, our business partners and the markets in which we operate. Under their stewardship, the Company has acquired a valuable portfolio of properties that Related now seeks to control.

Related/Corvex’s attempt to remove not only the current Board, but also any new trustees the Board may appoint, demonstrates that Related/Corvex only want control of the Company and do not care about the quality of the Board, in our view.

If you liked this article you might like

Wolfe Downgrades Dicks on E-Commerce Concerns

10 Sad Back-to-School Shopping Stores You Won't Be Visiting This Year

'I Love the Down-and-Outers': Cramer's 'Mad Money' Recap (Thursday 7/13/17)

Kroger, Square, Dycom: 'Mad Money' Lightning Round (5/30/17)