SEATTLE (TheStreet) -- Score one for Boeing (BA) in Friday's International Association of Machinists contract vote, in which 32,000 Boeing workers agreed to contract concessions in exchange for more jobs for Washington and more job security for themselves. Score one for Washington state, where Boeing will produce the 777X, its newest plane.
Also, score one for the IAM and its national leadership. The union got to the right answer despite a difficult negotiating environment in which two votes were rushed, workers had little information in the first election, the company held all the cards and the union's internal disagreement was publicly exposed. Democracy isn't pretty.
Who were the losers in the contract talks? That one is easy. Boeing said 22 states submitted proposals for 777X work. Washington won. South Carolina didn't get the 777X, but it did get a $1 billion expansion of its 787 facility.
So 20 states got nothing. Some including Washington publicly fawned over Boeing, offering all manners of tax incentives. Fawning over a company is unbecoming, but fawning and losing is even more so.
Overall, the Boeing contract negotiation story is a sign of the times. Big companies generally get what they want, whether by lobbying Congress or threatening to move. The union movement has been badly weakened in recent years, but it has managed to hang on at Boeing and at airlines and automakers.
And everywhere exists the belief that whatever works is worth doing. This belief inspires states and cities to compete against one another, not just for good jobs like those at Boeing but also, in far less logical scenarios, for professional sports teams.