Small-Cap Index Funds Fall Short

NEW YORK ( TheStreet ) -- With small stocks soaring in recent months, investors have poured into index exchange-traded funds and mutual funds that track the Russell 2000. During the past year, $4 billion has flowed into iShares Russell 2000 (IWM), the largest small-cap exchange-traded fund with $25 billion in assets.

But the index fund has delivered uninspiring results. During the past five years, iShares Russell 2000 returned 21.1% annually, outdoing 49% of small blend mutual funds. While the showing was not terrible, the results look disappointing when compared to the performance of S&P 500 index funds. During the past five years, SPDR S&P 500 (SPY), the largest S&P ETF, outdid 61% of large blend mutual funds. Proponents of passive investing have long argued that low-cost index funds should outdo most active mutual funds.

The weak showing of the Russell 2000 fund is not a fluke, according to research by ClearBridge Investments, which operates actively managed mutual funds. The researchers found that the Russell benchmark lagged most actively managed small-cap funds for the past 10 and 20 years.

Aram Green, a ClearBridge portfolio manager, says the index delivered poor results because of the way it is constructed. While the Russell 1000 includes the one thousand biggest stocks, the Russell 2000 benchmark covers stocks ranked by size from 1,001 through 3,000. The system automatically includes stocks that meet the size requirements, and there is no effort to exclude troubled companies.

Because many small-cap companies are shaky micro-caps with erratic sales, a big percentage of the names in the Russell 2000 are gushing red ink. In 2007, 430 of the 2,000 companies were losing money. The figure spiked to 734 in 2009 and declined to 534 in 2012. "When you own the Russell 2000 benchmark, you own a lot of companies with serious problems," says Green.

ClearBridge found that 10% of the small-cap companies that were in the index in 2007 eventually suffered huge losses as they went bankrupt, were delisted or acquired by another company at a low price. By avoiding the troubled companies, active managers outdid the benchmark. It was much harder to top the S&P 500 because the large-cap index includes mostly successful large companies. While 27% of Russell 2000 companies were losing money in 2012, only 6% of S&P 500 companies were in the red.

To hold small-caps, consider an active fund that has consistently outdone the benchmark by focusing on solid companies. Steady performers include Hodges Small Cap.



Hodges holds a mix of value and growth stocks that have flown under the radar. The aim is to find holdings that can surprise Wall Street by delivering long stretches of growth. During the past five years the fund returned 31.1% annually, outdoing 99% of peers.

Portfolio manager Eric Marshall likes to find cyclical companies that stand to gain as their industries consolidate and weaker competitors disappear. A favorite holding is Kapstone Paper and Packaging (KS).
Another holding is Shoe Carnival (SCVL).

RS Small Cap Growth aims to find companies that can increase revenues 15% annually for a full market cycle. The portfolio managers prefer businesses that can increase margins by maintaining clear competitive advantages. During the past five years, the fund returned 26.5% annually, outdoing 86% of small growth funds. A recent holding was Team Health (TMH).

William Blair Small-Mid Cap Growth aims to find quality companies that can deliver above-average growth for three to five years. Portfolio manager Rob Lanphier likes to buy promising small stocks and hold them until they become mid caps with capitalizations of up to $10 billion. During the past five years, the fund returned 24.1% annually, outdoing 86% of mid-growth peers. A holding is Pandora (P).

At the time of publication the author had no position in any of the stocks mentioned.

This article represents the opinion of a contributor and not necessarily that of TheStreet or its editorial staff.

Stan Luxenberg is a freelance writer specializing in mutual funds and investing. He was executive editor of Individual Investor magazine.

If you liked this article you might like

Novice Trade: Small-Cap Bear ETF

Novice Trade: Small-Cap Bear ETF

Indexes Are Holding Up Well, For Now

Indexes Are Holding Up Well, For Now

The Bounce Isn't Quite as Strong as It Looks

The Bounce Isn't Quite as Strong as It Looks

This Market Badly Needs a Rest

This Market Badly Needs a Rest

It Wasn't Just the Dollar

It Wasn't Just the Dollar