Kass: Apple's Strategic Blunder

This content originally appeared on Real Money Pro on Sept. 11.

NEW YORK ( Real Money) --

China is Apple's third-largest market. But after seeing some encouraging signs there, Apple reported that its "greater China" revenue (which includes Hong Kong and Taiwan) fell 14% in its most recent quarter from the same period a year earlier. It was down a whopping 43% from the previous quarter.

-- The Los Angeles Times

Just how far behind is Apple ( AAPL) trying to fall?

I do not get Tuesday's release and product launches. Something is just wrong.

Customers clearly want a big screen, yet Apple will not offer it.

The developed world is saturated with smartphones (at the high end), so future unit growth will be geared toward the emerging and undeveloped markets.

Emerging market customers are price-sensitive and want a lower-priced phone, yet Apple's newest iPhone dud won't hit a low enough price point that could drive market share gains and potentially lead to upward earnings revisions. (Note: There was no China phone announcement made Tuesday night.)

I fully recognize that Apple must somehow walk a tightrope between sustaining (elevated) profit margins and growing market share, but it did neither with Tuesday's announcements. Rather, it slipped badly.

From my perch, market share now is so valuable, not current gross margins -- it remains my view that Apple is making a strategic mistake. Is Apple trying to lose as much market share as possible in a world where the value of the market share is immense given the ecosystem that goes along with it?

Many in the Wall Street research community disagree with my view that giving up market share by retaining high average selling products is a tactical mistake (which will ultimately result in more margin degradation in the future).

  • Morgan Stanley -- new iPhones signal in-line units, better ASP/margins (Overweight): "We walk away from Apple's iPhone launch event with the view that estimates are likely to trend higher.... The iPhone 5c was priced higher than expected, which may limit unit upside but alleviates margin concerns and puts upward pressure on ASPs. Net, EPS estimates are likely to drift higher, especially if the potential China Mobile deal hits before year-end, pulling along the stock price, in our view."
  • Barclays -- new phones could have better margins than expected as pricing unchanged so far (Overweight): "In short, the pricing schemes are positive for margins as the products are basically in line with expectations...."

And then there is the iPad. There are now multiple lower-priced tablet devices just as good as Apple's iPad. Apple will begin to lose serious market share in the tablet market, a market that is already getting fairly saturated. (Remember: Apple's iPad business shrunk in units last quarter!)

The aggregate loss of market share at Apple across various products is a meaningful threat in the intermediate term. It is a circular issue, losing share in phones, more consumers get Android phones, then tablets, etc.

Market share expansion is now critical, so strategically, one has to be perplexed by Apple seemingly prioritizing margins (which still remain exposed and well above all competitors) over share gains.

If you liked this article you might like

Food Stocks Go Hungry; China Pressure -- Jim Cramer's Top Thoughts

Why Apple Is Increasingly Investing in Its Suppliers, Including Possibly Toshiba

Why Amazon's Reported Smart Glasses Might Be Just a Niche Product -- For Now

Driving This Beastly Cadillac CTS Reminded Me That Sexism Is Alive and Well