This column originally appeared on Real Money Pro at 12:47 p.m. EDT on Aug. 8.NEW YORK ( Real Money) -- As I will explain in this column, in the mortgage-servicing space I favor Ocwen Financial ( OCN) over Nationstar Mortgage Holdings ( NSM). Yesterday, mortgage servicer Nationstar Mortgage reported a beat to second-quarter 2013 expectations and initially ticked much higher in premarket trading, changing hands as high as $53 a share, up $4. (Note: The shares closed yesterday at $50 a share and are now trading lower at about $49.15 a share.) In my view, the gap was unjustified as the buyers and some of the sell-side analysts who applauded the report and the share price gap higher didn't appear to understand the quality of the earnings very well. I tried to short the stock but missed the trade. The reason I write this is because, among other liberal accounting recognition techniques, Nationstar utilizes a more aggressive gain-on-sale accounting in its earnings reports -- as such, I have an issue with Nationstar's quality of earnings. (I don't think this is well understood in the marketplace.) you will find in this column, if competitor Ocwen reported on a similar accounting basis (adding mortgage-servicing rights valuation adjustment and discount on advances), its second-quarter operating profits would have been over $400 million, and its pretax earnings would be $323.6 million compared to $199 million at Nationstar, rather than the reported pretax income of $87.5 million. If we further remove the impact of contribution to consumer relief fund, Ocwen's pretax income would have stood at $376.6 million vs. $199 million at Nationstar. Conversely, if Nationstar reported with the similar accounting conventions as Ocwen, taking out mortgage-servicing rights valuation adjustment and discount on advances, Nationstar's reported pretax income of $199 million would be adjusted and reduced to about $117 million. What follows is my more detailed analysis and calculation of how Nationstar's accounting policies differ appreciably with Ocwen's accounting.
Fine Points on Nationstar's AccountingDiscount on advances purchased is recognized under "interest income" in the proportion of advance collected:
- This component contributed $6.5 million to first-quarter 2013 earnings and $11.5 million to fourth-quarter 2012 earnings.
- The accurate number for second quarter 2013 will be disclosed in the 10Q, and we estimate it to be in the range of $20 million to $25 million.
- Nationstar increased its mortgage-servicing rights mark by $118 million.
- 50% of the benefit is passed onto excess spread holder.
- Unlike Ocwen, Nationstar does not have 100% ownership of mortgage-servicing rights.
- For first quarter 2013, it was $101 million -- the company does not provide any further details.
- The amount provisioned has been between $81 million and $83 million since second quarter 2012, though the servicing portfolio has more than doubled over the past year. This might be underprovided.
- Delinquent agency portfolios recently acquired should have increased this amount by $125 million to $150 million.
- The company recognizes a $7 million to $8 million loss on its legacy book every quarter despite improvements in credit and interest rate markets over the past two years.
- The legacy book might still be overvalued at $257 million.