BMW i3 vs. Tesla Model S: The Ultimate Comparison

NEW YORK (TheStreet) -- Having followed BMW's i3 electric car project for two years, I finallygot some time to examine the i3's interior in detail. The BMW i3 goeson sale in the U.S. in the first half of 2014.

With so relatively few plug-in electric cars in the market, it's not amajor exaggeration to say that in many cases they all compete againsteach other -- from those that cost under $30,000 to those that costover $90,000. That, of course, never happens with "regular"gasoline/diesel cars.

Let me explain: I have seen plenty of examples of people who, one ortwo years ago, bought a Nissan ( NSANY) LEAF or Chevrolet Volt, but previouslyonly purchased much more expensive cars --$100,000 and up. Likewise,more recently I have seen plenty of examples of people paying $100,000for a Tesla where they had never previously thought of buying a carthat's over $30,000.

The first implication of this phenomenon is that all the market-sizingestimates for electric cars are wrong. The market for electric carsis a lot larger than people think, even in the short run: People whocan afford expensive cars buy cheap EVs; people who never thoughtabout buying expensive cars before, now buy expensive EVs. This iswhy the Tesla ( TSLA) skeptics have been wrong at every turn.

This also has implications for the electric car intramural. Unlike inthe old-world gasoline/diesel market, where there are numerous choicesfor every automotive segment, the EV world has only a handful of carsbroadly available across the geographies, i.e., outside Californiawhere there are a few more choices.

Then you look at the sales statistics, you see that there are reallyonly three significantly electrified cars -- those that run onelectricity a vast majority of the time, or 100% of the time -- thathave sold in meaningful quantities: Chevrolet Volt, Nissan LEAF andTesla Model S. World-wide, Nissan has sold over 50,000, General Motors ( GM) approximately 50,000, and Tesla little over 15,000.

All in all, sales of all plug-in cars in the U.S. grew from 18,000 in2011 to 52,000 in 2012 to an estimated 100,000-125,000 for 2013. Itis in this context that BMW is starting to deliver the i3 in thecoming months.

The i3 comes in two main versions: One pure electric withapproximately 90 miles of range; the other with a gasoline generatorand 2.4 gallon (yes, two-point-four -- that's not a typo) gasolinetank. The generator will yield an extra range of approximately 90miles, and can be refueled at any gas station in seconds, just likeevery other car.

Compared to the Tesla, BMW i3 is shorter, narrower and taller. Theturning radius is tiny, and it's easy to park and place in citytraffic.

There is nothing on the road with the particular dimensions andarchitectural attributes of the BMW i3: Tall but narrow wheels,carbon-fiber plastic body, suicide doors with no B-pillar. Drivers ofthe BMW i3 will have people staring at them as if they were the firstto wear Google ( GOOG) Glass. The BMW i3 makes a very strong designstatement, arguably the strongest of any car in the market.

The interior also made it from the show car to the final productessentially unchanged. What does this mean? You have never seen acar interior like this. The dashboard alone would be the only one tobe featured in The Museum of Modern Art -- it's that special.

The shape and materials of the dashboard curves are not only extremelyattractive; they are also very practical. You can move from one sideof the car to the other, without meaningful obstruction from a centerstack.

The steering wheel has a uniquely shaped stalk-mounted gear shifter,and the steering wheel column has outstanding telescoping ability.Combined with an excellent seat, I was able to get a flawless seatingposition, which is sadly not available in all cars. It is equal tothe Tesla Model S.

What about Tesla's famous 17-inch screen with superior controls? Yes,it remains superior, except for the fact that it's huge and it'stherefore in the way from shifting from side to side in the car.BMW's dash looks a lot better from a MoMa perspective (i.e., withscreens turned off), but you can't beat Tesla's screen technology foractual use.

Basically, Tesla focused on a great seating position and the bestscreen/infotainment system in the industry, by far. BMW is just ascomfortable for the driver and passengers, but has a more beautifuland plush interior, although it is unlikely to come even remotelyclose to match Tesla's infotainment system.

The rear seat comparison is this: First of all, the Tesla fits threepeople; the BMW i3 only two. That is a deal-killer for some people,for sure. The Tesla also has slightly more leg and foot room.However, the BMW has more headroom, being comfortable for peoplealmost 5'11 tall.

Luggage space: Not a close call. Tesla wins, by a mile. The BMW hasa small but very usable space, and the rear seats fold flat. Not bad,but the Tesla is in a class by itself.

In terms of rendering a verdict for the interior comparison, you haveto put it into the context of price. A loaded BMW i3 with rangeextender will likely be around $50,000. Tesla's 85 kWh battery modelstarts at $81,400, and the 60 kWh model $71,400. You can add a lotequipment to those base Tesla prices.

Tesla's 85 kWh model gives you 265 miles of range, and even the 60 kWhmodel will handily exceed the BMW's 180-mile range. However, you canquickly add up to 90 miles (realistically 60-80 miles, given thenature of a gasoline tank that shouldn't be run down to zero) of rangein the BMW in a few seconds at positively any gasoline station. Sofrom this perspective, you could argue that the BMW is at least equaloverall compared to even the bigger Tesla battery version.

Performance-wise, the BMW i3 will lag the Tesla badly. The i3range-extender version will do 0-60 MPH in approximately 7.8 seconds,and the top speed is 93 MPH. Tesla is obviously much, much faster,even if most people may deem the BMW to be fast enough.

The BMW i3 may have an advantage in terms of cost of repair. Theouter body parts are mostly in plastic, and can withstand variouskicks and dings.

We are likely to start experiencing comprehensive drive tests of theBMW i3 in the U.S. perhaps in December. What I mean by that is journalists would drive the car for more than just a few hours, alonein their own home environment. This is opposed to controlled driveson test tracks and equivalent.

Some will argue passionately that Tesla and BMW i3 don't compete inany way. Surely, some people will not consider the other car, forgood reason. For example, the Tesla fits more people, more luggage,and it's faster. The BMW i3 will be easier to drive in small spaces,cost less, and it's got a spectacular design.

However, what I have learned from studying EV drivers is that there isa lot more purchase overlap than rational people would normallyassume. Many people just want a really cool car, as long as it'selectric in some form. For some of those people, they would considerboth the Tesla and BMW i3, and for good reason.

The BMW i3 vs Tesla battle is the one people are asking about first,because Tesla is such a high-flying stock. The answer is to someextent inconclusive. However, how does the BMW i3 compare toChevrolet Volt? Well, that will be the subject of another article.

Disclosure: BMW provided airfare, one night's stay in a hotel room and a handful of meals in order to enable this first-hand report fromthe launch event of the BMW i3.

At the time of publication the author was long GOOG.

This article was written by an independent contributor, separate from TheStreet's regular news coverage.

More from Technology

Amazon Wants to Use Your Car as a Mobile Warehouse - Here's What That Could Mean

Amazon Wants to Use Your Car as a Mobile Warehouse - Here's What That Could Mean

Twitter's Turnaround Continues but Investors Don't Seem Entirely Convinced

Twitter's Turnaround Continues but Investors Don't Seem Entirely Convinced

Will China Save Tesla?

Will China Save Tesla?

Will Alibaba Be the Next Big Player in Autonomous Driving?

Will Alibaba Be the Next Big Player in Autonomous Driving?

3 Hot Reads From TheStreet's Top Premium Columnists

3 Hot Reads From TheStreet's Top Premium Columnists