NEW YORK ( TheStreet) -- The consumer staples sector has been the most overvalued sector among the 16 that I track. On Dec. 26 I wrote, Consumer Staples Stocks Are Holiday Laggards, and since then these nine stocks performed nicely. Today all nine are rated buy according to ValuEngine, but two were downgraded to buy from strong buy during the first quarter.Today www.ValuEngine.com shows that 64% of all stocks are overvalued, just 1% below a ValuEngine Valuation Warning. The consumer staples sector is 25.9% overvalued in a tie with the transportation sector. Last week I wrote, 12 Sell Downgrades Threaten Dow Transports and today I am concerned that this contagion can spread to consumer staples. The nine consumer stocks are more overvalued today than at the end of 2012, less so than the sector.
All nine are trading above their 200-day simple moving averages which reflects the risk of a reversion to this mean. Wall Street continues to tell investors that stocks are cheap given a 15 price-to-earnings ratio for the S&P 500. ValuEngine incorporates this data in its valuation model, as both the 12-month trailing and 12-month forward P/E are two of the three most heavily weighed factors in determining the fair value price of every stock. The 12-month trailing P/E for the nine stocks profiled today are elevated at 17.5 to 24.7. Given my analysis a buy-and-trade strategy remains in play for these stocks, but its time to clean up positions by reducing exposures on strength to risky levels.