NEW YORK ( TheStreet) --Mortgage REITs were having a brilliant year in 2012, but ran into a brick wall some three weeks ago, and there is some disagreement among analysts over whether the sector will redeem itself when companies report third quarter earnings. From the start of the year through Sept. 21, Market Vectors ETF Trust ( MORT), a mortgage REIT exchange traded fund, gained 23.87%, not counting its sizeable dividend yield (currently just below 10%). From Sept. 24 through Thursday, however, the fund has fallen 5.5% on worries over shrinking dividends. Some commentators have pinned the blame on QE3--specifically, the Federal Reserve's Sept. 13 announcement that it would buy long-dated mortgage backed securities in an effort to stimulate home purchases by lowering the mortgage rate for prospective new homebuyers. Mortgage REITs use leverage to buy mortgage backed securities (MBS) and profit on the spread between the dividend income and their (relatively lower) cost of raising money to buy more MBS. Lower yields on long-dated MBS means rising book values for mortgage REITs because the MBS they own rise in value. However, the lower long term yields mean that when MBS mature, the mortgage REITs must reinvest their earnings at lower yields. Further, mortgage REITs face a rising risk of prepayment as homeowners pay off mortgages in order to refinance at lower rates. However, Sterne Agee analyst Jason Weaver argues in a report published Thursday these risks "have been apparent for some time, thus we find it unlikely to be the driver of recent sector weakness as commonly cited." Rather, Weaver attributes the recent selloff to investors pocketing gains and reallocating money to sectors that haven't performed as well. Barclays analyst Mark DeVries, however, expressed concern on Tuesday that attempts by REITs such as American Capital Agency Corp. ( AGNC), Annaly Capital Management ( NLY)and CYS Investments ( CYS), which focus on MBS issued by government-sponsored enterprises Fannie Mae ( FNMA)and Freddie Mac ( FMCC) to hedge their exposure to rising interest rates may have offset their QE3-driven book value gains. Weaver, on the other hand, does not share those concerns. He sees "a good possibility of significant upside surprises" on earnings and book value, particularly for American Capital Agency Corp. He did not address Annaly or CYS in his report.
Both analysts, however, are positive on Two Harbors Investment Corp. ( TWO). DeVries argues "it is more leveredto continued improvement in the housing market," while Weaver cites positive commentary from the company about rising book values. Two Harbors, however, hasn't sold off with much of the rest of the sector. On Thursday, it closed just 3.1% below its 52 week high. American Capital Agency Corp., by contrast, is nearly 10% off its high. -- Written by Dan Freed in New York. Follow @dan_freed