Follow Your Gut, and Dow Theory

NEW YORK ( TheStreet) -- I have heard far too often (to the point of annoyance) that in a digital world, Dow Transportation stocks matter less in terms of their ability to predict where the markets are headed.

It seems as if investors forget that physical goods, including the service personnel that drive the service economy, cannot be transported through a computer. Everything still needs to be shipped.

I'm inclined to believe paying less attention to the Dow Transportation stocks is a big mistake. I am not the first to say this, but instead reiterating advice that has proven reliable and successful.

Specifically, one of the six basic tenets of the Dow Theory is that the Dow Jones Industrial Average and the Dow Jones transportation index should move in the same direction. When the averages diverge, it's a warning that change is coming and likely not positive change.

I feel the warnings issued by FedEx ( FDX), Norfolk Southern ( NSC) and Caterpillar ( CAT) two weeks ago, was the first alarm bell. Unfortunately, this warning was shrugged off by stampeding bulls.

From 1953 to 2011, incorporating the tenets of Dow Theory -- which includes paying attention to the transports -- has produced an excess return of 1.5% annually over a buy and hold strategy. This was the conclusions of a study marking the 160th birthday of Charles Dow. For many years the Dow Theory was discarded, but a newer analysis found that on a risk adjusted basis, Dow Theory delivers alpha.

I would remind investors that alpha works to the downside as well as the upside. That is, losing less than the markets at large is, in the twisted scorekeeping of investors, a win. It's true, investors should never use a single indicator as a guide to decision making.

However, if the trend in transportation stocks is another data point confirming your suspicions, I would urge you to follow your gut and take some risk off the table.

This article was written by an independent contributor, separate from TheStreet's regular news coverage.
Oliver Pursche is President of Gary Goldberg Financial Services, a boutique money management firm located in Suffern, NY. Additionally, Mr. Pursche is the Co-Portfolio Manager for the GMG Defensive Beta Fund, and a Founding Partner of Montebello Partners, llc. In his role as President of GGFS, and as a member of the GGFS Investment Committee, Mr. Pursche helps oversee the investment portfolio of over 2000 clients with over $500 million dollars in assets. Mr. Pursche frequently provides market and economic commentary on CNBC and Fox Business News, as well as often being interviewed by The Financial Times, US News and World Report, Thomson Reuters, Bloomberg Businessweek, and the Associated Press regarding his and the firms views on the latest market news and events. Mr. Pursche's views on the market and investment strategies have been featured in the Wall Street Journal, Investors Business Daily, Smart Money, USA Today and other national business publications. In addition to writing for TheStreet.com, he is also a weekly contributor on Forbes.com and BankRate.com. His daily market commentary can be read at www.betafundcommentary.com or you can listen to him on www.financialtalkshow.com weekdays at 10:00 AM.

If you liked this article you might like

Tax Reform Is Coming and That Means Trump Stock Rally Is Ready to Kill It Again

'Trump Stock' Rally Is Back on Track

Caterpillar Reports 11% Jump in Global Machine Retail Sales in August

FedEx Makes A Comeback: Cramer's Top Takeaways

Watch Out For the Dominoes That Fall: Cramer's 'Mad Money' Recap (Wed 9/20/17)