Can iPhone 5 Sales Record Buy Best Buy Some Time?

NEW YORK ( TheStreet) -- Best Buy ( BBY) is the largest independent retailer of smartphone products. The Apple ( AAPL) iPhone 5 pre-order period has already set a record. Renowned economists are estimating iPhone 5 sales will be a major boost to U.S. GDP. So why won't the iPhone 5 spending surge be a lasting stimulus for the struggling electronics retailer?

Record iPhone 5 sales may provide a small, short-tern earnings boost for Best Buy as the company's new chief executive Hubert Joly tries to resize the business and fend off a buyout effort by co-founder and former CEO Richard Schulze.

However, even if the iPhone 5 generates the type of consumer demand that would normally play to the favor of an electronics retailer and which Nobel Laureate Paul Krugman estimates could add up to 0.5% to overall U.S. GDP (JPMorgan Chase puts it between 0.25% and 0.5%), Best Buy shareholders shouldn't expect a material impact on the company's turnaround or takeover prospects.

Even though it is the largest independent retailer of smartphone products, Best Buy is challenged by Apple and wireless carriers like AT&T ( T) and Verizon ( VZ) for direct iPhone sales.

Meanwhile, in the sale of iPhone accessories and ancillary products, which may need upgrading because of the iPhone 5 Lightning connector cable, online electronics retailers including Amazon ( AMZN) may have the pricing advantage.

"I don't think we are going to see enough of an impact from iPhone sales for there to be a material change," says RJ Hottovy, a retail analyst at Morningstar. In fact, trends in how handset manufacturers launch new products in the hyper-competitive smartphone market may be playing against Best Buy's favor. "The success of iPhone launches will continue to have less benefit for Best Buy over time," says Hottovy, citing the growth of Apple branded stores and a consumer shift to online orders.

Apple Stores have pulled iPhone sales inward, and as the company takes creator control of its product launches, competitors like Microsoft may yet follow suit, to the detriment of Best Buy. The iPhone 5 is the marquee product in a new wave of smartphone launches that includes Nokia's ( NOK) Windows-based phone and Google's ( GOOG) recently acquired Motorola Mobility RAZR line, all testing the power structure of the market.

Hottovy and other analysts concede that new smartphone products led by the iPhone 5 will have an obvious incremental benefit to Best Buy's earnings in the near-term, but can't solve the big Best Buy problem of sustaining electronics spending in-store.

Non-iPhone smartphone launches like Nokia's Lumia, which runs on Microsoft's soon-to-be released Windows 8 operating system, may prove to be the most critical test for Best Buy of cashing in on smartphone launch season, even if it's iPhone sales that set records.

If you liked this article you might like

Best Buy CEO -- We, Together With Amazon, Will 'Kill' the Competition

Wall Street Overlooks Trump's North Korea Threats to Hit New Records

Best Buy Disappointment Sends Retailers Into a Spin

Stocks on Track for Records Even as Trump Goes After North Korea