NEW YORK ( TheStreet)--Small tech startup Aereo.com, partly owned by IAC/InterActiveCorp ( IACI), recently won an important skirmish on par with David vs. Goliath against several well-known large broadcasters and content providers.Aereo provides a web service that uses antennas to receive broadcast TV signals and makes the programming available to Aereo subscribers on the internet. Aereo currently limits its offering to New York City. Users are able to watch high-definition TV from a portable device live or record programming for later viewing. CBS ( CBS), Comcast ( CMCSA), Walt Disney/ ( DIS), News Corp. ( NWSA) and other broadcasters are suing Aereo for what they contend is Aereo's public broadcasting of their content without permission and without paying royalty fees. ( TheStreet's Gary Krakow writes more about Barry Diller and Aereo
Aereo fired back at the broadcasters and stated the technology it employs is perfectly legal and cited several previous court cases including at least one from the U.S. Supreme Court. The Federal Communications Commission requires broadcasters to offer their programming over the airways free of charge in return for broadcasters' use of the radio spectrum. Aereo claims that because every Aereo customer is provided their own antenna at Aereo's location to pick up the signal, Aereo's service does not fall within the meaning of a public broadcast. Furthermore, Aereo claims its recording service is no different from that of a household VCR or the Cablevision ruling on digital recordings. In the Cablevision case, a federal court ruled "each RS-DVR playback transmission is made to a single subscriber using a single unique copy produced by that subscriber ...such transmissions are not performances 'to the public.' " Even in a cloud storage situation, each subscriber needs to have their own copy of the same programming. In hopes of a quick Aereo death, the aforementioned broadcasters filed a request for a temporary injunction against Aereo to stop its service. On Wednesday U.S. District Judge Alison Nathan for the Southern District of New York ruled in favor of Aereo and denied the motion, thereby allowing Aereo to continue while the case makes its way through the court system.