The company blamed the decline in production on aging fields as well as contracts with foreign governments that limited oil and gas sales. As disappointing as these numbers were the company did report operating cash flow of $21.8 billion -- appreciably above its earnings. Among other positives was the fact that not only has the company recently boosted it dividends to become the highest payer in the world, but it has also been spending its excess cash repurchasing as much as $5 billion of its own stock.

Moving ahead

As far as outlook is concerned analysts are projecting sales growth of 3% -- a figure that I consider pretty meek for a company the size of Exxon on total sales of $500 billion. Consensus earnings estimates have a target of $8.29 for the balance of 2012, while the number for 2013 currently stands at $8.88. So when factoring Wednesday's closing stock price of $86.20 the stock is expected to trade at its current multiple with not much movement over the next 12 -- 18 months whereas, in my estimation, Halliburton is projected to increase by at least 33% based on these same factors. So from that standpoint, it would appear that Halliburton remains the better buy.

Overall, Exxon did as good of a job as could have been expected. And although I would insist that the stock is fairly valued at current levels, it is hard to ignore the positive impact that the shares may experience once natural gas prices start to show some signs of life -- particularly when one considers how effective Exxon has been in balancing its U.S. exposure by forging international deals.

Bottom line

The investment case for Exxon often comes down to safety. While the stock is not going to excite investors to the extent that an Apple can, it does however present little to no downside risk. The company has huge reserves and plenty of capital which often is an appealing quality to conservative investors. It has nearly three times the market cap of several of its rival but it is far from a lumbering, stumbling giant.

The company is still in the mix of all phases of upstream and downstream operations, and its portfolio of exploration and production projects should serve to mitigate concerns through lean times such as these. Exxon should be considered as part of any portfolio with realistic investment horizons and more importantly, patience. That said, for investors looking of at least 30% gain over that same period, Halliburton would instead be the name to consider.

At the time of publication, the author held no positions in any of the stocks mentioned, although positions may change at any time.

If you liked this article you might like

These Stocks Pay You to Own Them

Dow, S&P 500 Set New Records as Fed Moves to Unwind Balance Sheet

Stocks In Negative Territory as Chances for December Hike Surge

Energy Stocks Lead a Neutral Market Even After Oil Inventories Spike

Energy Takes a Backseat as Crude Oil Stabilizes Under $50