Some of these products have been adopted by major financial institutions. Last year, Citi ( C) announced a Thank You 2G card, which allows its cardholders to pay with their credit line or rewards points. US Bank ( USB) has offered its Mastercard ( MA) Pay Pass VITAband -- essentially a wristband that gives its wearer the ability to make purchases via a reloadable prepaid chip -- since July, and Fifth Third Bank ( FITB) introduced a dual credit/debit card in September.

But thus far, these products have failed to trigger a full on revolution. Citi debuted its 2G card at the Consumer Electronics Show in 2011, but has yet to offer it to the mainstream public.

"It is available to a small group of people and is something we are continuing to accept feedback on," a Citi spokeswoman said.

Hornblass believes mass adoption has been delayed because no bank or issuer is featuring a product advanced enough to inspire consumers to switch from what they are used to. Citi and Fifth Third's cards, for instance, don't have a feature that allows for secure contact-less payments, while US Bank's wristband doesn't link to multiple accounts.

"If the payment method doesn't have the full menu of innovations available, that's a strike against it," he says, adding that many of these products may cost the issuer more to provide than a traditional credit card would.

These complications have led to a wave of innovations that focus on adding to what the credit card can do without having to change the plastic itself.

If you liked this article you might like

Sneaky Rally; Wells Fargo Needs Outside Help -- Jim Cramer's Top Thoughts

Apple Is the Tom Brady of Stocks: Cramer's 'Mad Money' Recap (Thursday 8/31/17)

Cramer: Fantasy Shmantasy -- Let's Get Real With These Stock Picks

Visa, MasterCard, Discover Offer Secured Credit Cards, a Tool for College Kids

Cognizant Technology, Advanced Micro Devices: 'Mad Money' Lightning Round