Why Zynga's IPO Fell Flat




By Julia Boorstin, CNBC Correspondent

NEW YORK ( CNBC) -- Zynga's ( ZNGA) long-anticipated IPO did not benefit from the same first-day bumps that sent LinkedIn ( LNKD) and Groupon ( GRPN) soaring higher earlier this year.

The social gaming company raised $1 billion -- issuing 100 million shares at $10 a share -- making it the largest Internet-related IPO since Google's ( GOOG) $1.4 billion offering back in 2004. The $10 price was at the upper end of the $8.50-$10 range, valuing the company at around $7 billion, $8.9 billion including unexercised options and warrants.

Zynga's valuation may be huge compared to video game giants Electronic Arts ( ERTS) -- $6.9 billion -- and Activision Blizzard ( ATVI) -- $13.6 billion. But it's actually much smaller than expected. Earlier this year the company was valued at $14 billion -- it sold shares to investors for around $14. Some industry watchers talked about a $20 billion valuation and some employees reportedly were granted stock options at a higher valuation than $14 billion.
More from CNBC
Still a Season for Miracles to Happen
The Grinch Who Stole Your Bonus
Payroll Taxes and a Two-Santa Theory

As soon as Zynga priced Thursday night, it was clear that this stock would not see the massive first-day jump investors were trained to expect by LinkedIn and Groupon to expect. Yes, Zynga priced at the upper end of its range, but the company could have priced as high as $12 per share without re-issuing its S-1 SEC filing. And, on top of that, the company had the option of issuing an additional 15 million shares of stock. Yes, this means that the stock was priced accurately, but it also means that the company didn't see the massive demand it was prepared to handle.

So what went wrong? Zynga's rare in its pre-IPO profits -- $90.6 million in 2010. But Wall Street seems to have soured on Internet fare. Groupon shares, after jumping 40% opening day from its $20 IPO price, fell to as low as $15 before rebounding a bit. And Pandora ( P) is pretty much flat from where it started trading in June.

Analysts have been piling on Zynga, warning about its growth prospects. Cowen & Co analyst Doug Creutz initiated coverage with a neutral rating, warning that Zynga's market share of Facebook gaming is declining and Facebook gaming growth is slowing. Stern Agee's Arvind Bhatia, rated the stock a sell before it priced, warning about slowing growth and declining free cash flow.

Plus, while investors may be look to Zynga for access to the social media space, once Facebook goes public, Wall Street will no longer need that proxy.

-- Written by Julia Boorstin, CNBC Correspondent
CNBC is a world leader in business news, providing real-time financial market coverage and business information.

If you liked this article you might like

How to Avoid Making One of the Most Lethal Investing Mistakes Around

Go Inside Google's 'Moonshot' Project That Aims to Succeed Where Lyft Failed

One Number Shows Snap Has Almost No Chance to Dethrone Facebook

Why Investors Should Factor in Goodwill When Evaluating Stocks