Are Users Set to Abandon Android?

The following commentary comes from an independent investor or market observer as part of TheStreet's guest contributor program, which is separate from the company's news coverage.

NEW YORK ( TheStreet) -- The multiple of "anecdote" is "statistics." Where am I going with this?

If you are interested in the smartphone wars, you will note two thingsabout the Android platform and the U.S. market for smartphones inparticular. Android took off in the U.S. starting in November 2009with Verizon's ( VZ) launch of the first Droid model. As of July 2011, astaggering 550,000 Androids were activated world-wide daily. In theU.S. market, the vast majority of Android activations have taken placeon two-year contracts, the first of whom are coming due in the nextfive weeks.

Having over-taken Apple's ( AAPL) iOS (iPhone, iPad, iPod Touch and Apple TV)in terms of unit volume, what will happen when these two-year Androidcontracts roll over? Will something happen even before they do, suchas when the iPhone 5 is expected to become available here in October?

Here is when the multiple of anecdote, i.e., statistics, enter thepicture. I have not conducted a scientific survey on this subject,let alone a statistically significant one. I have only askedapproximately 100 people I know who have been Android users foranywhere between one week and two years. In addition, I have beenpaying attention to comments from numerous other people on messageboards and hearing from friend-of-friends.

A few months ago, all of these anecdotes started to develop a clearpattern. Let's be blunt and get to the bottom line: A very largeshare of Android users are unhappy to some degree, and intend toswitch platforms either when the iPhone 5 becomes available, or whentheir two-year contracts expire.

Battery Life

So what kind of complaints are we talking about precisely? Oneparticular complaint appears to dominate almost completely: batterylife. I can't recall a single Android user I've talked to whodoesn't complain in a very angry tone about battery life. Basically,they love the smartphone's capabilities, but it is a useless brickwhen the battery goes out.

Many Android users not only know that they are experiencingunsatisfactory battery life, but also that some of the competingplatforms such as iOS and BlackBerry typically offer much betterbattery life. They know it when they go out for the evening and theAndroid is dead after three hours or less, whereas the iPhone andBlackBerry devices carried by their friends are still going strong fiveor 10 hours thereafter.

Other complains about Android appear far more scattered and uneven.Some find the interface a bit complicated. Others don't like themedia options when compared to iTunes. Overall system stability andconsistency may be an issue. And so forth.

This isn't to say that Android doesn't have strong advantages as well. After all, something attracted the consumer to Android to begin with! Some of these pluses include:
  • 1. Superior and free navigation.
  • 2. LTE availability on Verizon today, and soon on AT&T.
  • 3. Unmatched variety of form factors, including screen sizes, cameras, etc.
  • 4. Availability on all carriers, with at least some pre-paid options.
  • 5. A cheap initial purchase price.
  • 6. Excellent integration with all of Google's great cloud services.
  • 7. No need to sync over a cable; full cloud activation.
  • 8. Ability to root and install custom ROM.
  • This list makes it clear that there are compromises no matter whichplatform you choose. There is at least one point or two where each ofAndroid, iOS, BlackBerry and Microsoft have an edge over theircompetitors. No one platform is best at everything. Every consumerhas a sub-optimal trade-off to make.

    The fact that each platform has both strengths and weaknesses,however, doesn't mean that market share gains and losses will remainthe same over time, or across geographies. For example, Android hasexploded progressively across almost all geographies in less than 24months. BlackBerry has recently lost a lot of market share in NorthAmerica, but continues to gain strong ground in many internationalmarkets ranging from Malaysia to Nigeria and Philippines.

    Speaking mostly from a North American perspective, I hear a very largepercentage of Android users looking to change relatively soon. Idon't hear any of that from iOS, and BlackBerry is somewherein-between, ranging from frustrated users in need of better media andapps, to fans of the basic typing productivity experience.

    The other peculiarity of the U.S. market is this combination:
  • 1. High subsidies for the iPhone, leading to a relatively small pricedifference against the other players. Outside North America, iPhonestypically cost closer to $900 including taxes.
  • 2. Apple offers its complete set of software, services and storeassets in the U.S. to the greatest extent anywhere in the world. Thismeans Apple is uniquely strong, relatively speaking, here in the U.S.compared to in most or all other countries.
  • What does all of this mean? It means that outside of the geek worldin which users tinker with their devices, many are fed up with poorbattery life and perhaps another lesser issue or two, and will switchto the iPhone 5 or other devices within the next two years.

    Enter iPhone 5

    Given that we are on the eve of the iPhone 5 with its new iOS 5.0 andthe new iCloud improvements to the iOS ownership experience, it isnatural to believe that Apple will take all of the gains resultingfrom Android's losses. This may very well be largely true in the nearterm.

    However, Microsoft is finally entering the market with a competitiveproduct built on hardware by HTC, Dell, Samsung, LG and others. Thenew BlackBerry Bold 9900 series is also a very strong step forward andcould lure some people away from Android who simply prefer somethingthat "just works." Then in 2012, we expect RIM ( RIMM) to launch itsnext-generation BlackBerry smartphones based on the all-new QNXoperating system, which will have some Android app compatibility --but presumably without the bad Android battery life.

    This phenomenon should be far less pronounced in particular in Asia,for the reasons outlined above. Purchase price matters a lot more,and it appears that the Asian gadget psyche may be more in tune withthe more complicated Android interface and customization capabilities. Europe may be somewhere in-between North America and Asia in thisregard.

    Google ( GOOG) is not sitting still with Android, and is also on the cusp ofthe next major software release, 4.0 Ice Cream Sandwich, probably herein October and availability by November or so. It appears thatAndroid 4.0, however, may be a less of a step forward when compared tothe major step forward that Apple is taking with iOS in going from4.3.5 to 5.0.

    If you are skeptic about my assertion in this article -- that Androidwill lose market share in the U.S. over the next year ortwo -- conduct a small survey of your own. Ask how many of yourAndroid friends are fed up to the point where they are eager toswitch, and then do the same for your iPhone friends. I think youwill find that it's not a close call. Furthermore, I think you willfind that battery life is the #1 standout on the list of reasons.

    Bottom line: I think a much larger share of the U.S. market than isusual in a product cycle will leave Android in favor of the iPhone 5,and perhaps even some to BlackBerry's new products or the newMicrosoft Phone 7.5 smartphones.

    At the time of submitting this article to publication, the author waslong AAPL, GOOG and RIMM.

    This commentary comes from an independent investor or market observer as part of TheStreet guest contributor program. The views expressed are those of the author and do not necessarily represent the views of TheStreet or its management.

    Anton Wahlman was a sell-side equity research analyst covering the communications technology industries from 1996 to 2008: UBS 1996-2002, Needham & Company 2002-2006, and ThinkEquity 2006-2008.

    More from Technology

    Attention 60 Minutes: Google Isn't the Only Big-Tech Monopoly

    Attention 60 Minutes: Google Isn't the Only Big-Tech Monopoly

    Listen: Should You Buy Cisco Now?

    Listen: Should You Buy Cisco Now?

    Apple Buys Tesla? Amazon Buys Sears? 3 Dream Mergers That Just Make Sense

    Apple Buys Tesla? Amazon Buys Sears? 3 Dream Mergers That Just Make Sense

    Amazon Could Devastate Walgreens and Rite Aid by Getting Into Pharmacy Business

    Amazon Could Devastate Walgreens and Rite Aid by Getting Into Pharmacy Business

    Why PayPal's CEO Doesn't Fear Amazon Entering Mobile Payments

    Why PayPal's CEO Doesn't Fear Amazon Entering Mobile Payments