Shipyard Pumpkinhead Ale
BeerAdvocate rating: C
RateBeer Rating: 35 of 100

Shipyard Smashed Pumpkin
BeerAdvocate rating: B
RateBeer Rating: 88 of 100
There are two big complaints about Pumpkinhead: Those who love it tend to have a hard time finding it, and those who hate it feel it tastes of a whole lot of cinnamon and fizz but little to no pumpkin.

For the former who like their malted beverages a little bubbly and spicy, Shipyard started brewing Pumpkinhead in July and won't stop until November. That's great news for casual pumpkin ale drinkers who are big fans of Blue Moon-style wheat beer in the summer, but like a pumpkin ale with sugar and cinnamon around the rim of the glass in winter.

For the latter, the 5.1% ABV Pumpkinhead is going to bear little to no resemblance to the mortar-and-pestle pumpkin concoction Pugsley first made in a brewpub kitchen more than 15 years ago. These folks might want to go with a foil-wrapped 22-ounce bomber of the bigger 9% ABV Smashed Pumpkin. It has far more kick than Pumpkinhead, a much more balanced blend of spices, a subtle touch of hops and the overall flavor of spiked pumpkin pie.

"Unlike Pumpkinhead, this is a sit-down, sip-by-the-fire type of beer," Pugsley says. "I almost liken it to a port as a fun, nice after-dinner type drink."

While a $9 to $10 sixer Pumpkinhead would go just fine with candy corn and fun-sized Snickers, Shipyard suggests pairing a similarly priced bottle of Smashed Pumpkin with sharp cheeses, nuts, flan or pumpkin pie. Cooking with it isn't out of the question, either.

If you liked this article you might like

10 Winter Beers Here Before Halloween

Democrats Target Megamergers in Populist Political Play

Walmart Is One of 63 Companies Contributing Massively to Aid Harvey Relief

Corporate America Wants a Piece of the Mayweather, McGregor Money Giveaway

With Eyes on Solar Eclipse, Wall Street Stumbles Yet Again