S&P Downgrade of U.S. Debt Would Be 'Right Thing'

BOSTON (TheStreet) -- On March 28, after a week that saw the Dow Jones Industrial Average jump 3%, money manager Jeffrey Sica predicted that the borrowing and spending by the U.S. would prompt a downgrade of U.S. debt. Four months later, it appears that gloomy prediction will come true.

Sica, who is president and chief investment officer of Morristown, N.J.-based Sica Wealth Management, a firm with about $1 billion in assets under management, says Standard & Poor's has to make good on the threat to downgrade U.S. debt or lose credibility forever.

With a debt deal now in place, Sica is bracing for a downgrade of U.S. debt by credit ratings agencies by making what some have called unpatriotic bets: short U.S. Treasuries, short the U.S. dollar, move to higher levels of cash and buy commodities like oil, silver and gold.

Standard & Poor's warned in June that it would downgrade the triple-A rating of U.S. debt if significant progress were not made in dealing with a ballooning deficit. The compromise reached by President Obama and congressional leaders over the weekend, which was approved during a House vote Monday evening, calls for up to $2.4 trillion in savings over the next 10 years.

While that raises the U.S. debt from $14.3 trillion through the end of 2012, the credit ratings agency had warned the U.S. would need a plan that would lead to $4 trillion in savings, although the agency has backed off that number in the last few days amid heavy lobbying from the government. "It's thuggery," Sica says.

With a Treasury-imposed deadline to raise the debt ceiling only hours away and with a Senate vote scheduled for 12 p.m. ET, investors have lost faith that Congress can reach a deal that will satisfy S&P analysts and avoid a downgrade. The Dow has dropped 4.7% over seven consecutive losing sessions, and futures were sinking lower Tuesday before the opening bell. Sica, though, isn't surprised by the market's reaction.

"In March, I looked at what a colossal failure our government had been at stimulating the economy, and I knew that there was no way these oppositional views would come together," Sica says. "Based on the divisive views from the two parties in Congress, you knew it was going to become an issue. The political divide was becoming extremely evident back in March. Now here we are at the precipice, and it's gotten even more divisive."

Sica, who is also a former managing director for Wells Fargo, argues that the debt ceiling debate is being handled as a political issue when it's really an economic issue.

"Politicians on both sides are saying S&P should not involve itself with political issues," Sica says. "That is the most erroneous comment they can make. Politicians themselves made an economic issue into a political issue."

The bickering across the aisle in Congress will force the S&P's hand, he says. "There will be a downgrade. There is no doubt about it. There has to be."

For some market observers, it's hard to take a downgrade from credit ratings agencies seriously. After all, these were the same entities that continued to award triple-A ratings to asset classes that imploded in 2008 during the housing crisis. After the debacle with collateralized-debt obligations, or CDOs, S&P and other ratings agencies are stuck between a rock and a hard place.

"I would not want to be working for S&P right now and making this decision," Sica says. "Either S&P will step up and do the right thing or they'll lose credibility forever. They'll face tons of criticism from the government, even though the government screwed this up to begin with. This could be S&P's moment to stick to their mandate and show the reason they've existed to begin with."

Under the S&P guidelines, the agency must look forward from three months to longer than a year in order to assign a credit rating. While the government could come to a temporary solution to raise the debt ceiling, Sica says that S&P will be forced to act and protect its damaged credibility if congressional leaders offer no plan to deal with permanent changes to entitlement programs that could lead to severe deficit problems in the future.

"They can't embrace quick-fix solutions. Any potential solution would avoid default, but they need to justify the coveted triple-A rating," Sica says. "They need to address the overriding issue. Entitlement programs have been a third rail for both parties in Congress. They won't touch them. If you have any debt and you simply pay interest with no reduction in principle, you do not warrant a triple-A rating. That rating belongs to surplus-oriented entities."

Sica doesn't expect a full-blown Armageddon if the U.S. loses its prestigious triple-A rating, but the outcome is certainly not all sunshine and flowers. After a downgrade from the S&P, Sica says pension funds with mandates of triple-A rated holdings will be forced to sell government issues, triggering a surge in yields as prices plummet. Borrowing costs will increase as the biggest holders of debt lose faith in the U.S. government and sell Treasuries.

Outside of the bond market, the dollar will decline against the yen, euro and Swiss franc, Sica predicts. Money markets will trade below net asset value, which could prompt nervous selling, he says. Consumer confidence will plunge further as well. The Bloomberg U.S. Consumer Comfort Index fell to a reading of -46.8 last week from a prior reading of -43.3, a sign that consumers are very pessimistic already.

Among equities, companies with solid earnings such as Microsoft ( MSFT) and Coca-Cola ( KO) could see revenue decrease as borrowing costs rise, Sica contends.

Because of his view, Sica is positioning his investors for a downgrade. His strategy is straightforward, as he's increasing his cash levels to over 50%, he's holding about 10% to 15% of his assets in precious metals like gold and silver, and he is buying oil-related assets as he expects oil prices to continue higher. He is a buyer of the iShares Dow Jones U.S. Oil Equipment Index ( IEZ) and the iShares Dow Jones U.S. Oil & Gas Exploration Index ( IEO).

On the other hand, Sica says he has cut his position in equities to under 10%. Most of the stocks his firm owns are related to mining, like Freeport-McMoRan ( FCX). "We feel a lot more comfortable with stocks like that because there is not a lot of supply of gold or silver," Sica says. "We've been buying those types of companies."

Gold and silver trades have been extremely profitable lately on rising fear. For example, the SPDR Gold Trust ETF ( GLD) has jumped 8.2% in July, and the iShares Silver Trust ETF ( SLV) has jumped an impressive 13.6%.

Sica is also making several politically unpopular bets, such as shorting the U.S. Treasury as well as the dollar. That bet is based on the expectation that bond yields will rise and the dollar will depreciate. He is buying exchange-traded funds that are short Treasuries, including the ProShares Short 7-10 Year Treasury ETF ( TBX), the ProShares UltraShort 20+ Year Treasury ETF ( TBT) and the ProShares UltraShort 3-7 Year Treasury ETF ( TBZ), to capitalize on the inevitable rise in interest rates.

"I've had people say it's politically incorrect to bet against the U.S. Treasury," Sica says. "People will say that it's unpatriotic. I'm very patriotic in my love for this country and everything about this country. But what has made this country great is our economic responsibility to our taxpayers and citizens. From my core function to manage money professionally, we feel the U.S. Treasury will fall in price and rise in yield. We're using strategies that will profit from that."

-- Written by Robert Holmes in Boston.

>To contact the writer of this article, click here: Robert Holmes.

Related Articles:


Disclosure: TheStreet's editorial policy prohibits staff editors, reporters and analysts from holding positions in any individual stocks.

More from Personal Finance

Summer Travel: The Best Places to Visit in the U.S.

Summer Travel: The Best Places to Visit in the U.S.

9 Best Investment Books for Beginners

9 Best Investment Books for Beginners

How to Calculate Your Net Worth and Pin Down Your Financial Health

How to Calculate Your Net Worth and Pin Down Your Financial Health

The Best States for Millennials' Money and Health

The Best States for Millennials' Money and Health

U.S. Banks Urged to Make Small Loans In Competition With Payday Lenders

U.S. Banks Urged to Make Small Loans In Competition With Payday Lenders