In Your 40s? Avoid the IRA 'Double Tax'

NEW BERLIN, Ill. ( TheStreet) -- Chances are, especially if you hold a significant amount of money in IRA accounts, you've heard about a "double tax" that may be a part of your account's future.

Here's a brief explanation: When the owner of an IRA dies, assuming the size of the estate is greater than the exclusion amount, the estate has to pay tax on any amount above the exclusion. Presumably this includes an IRA account, 401(k) and other retirement plans ... and when heirs begin taking Required Minimum Distributions from the IRA account, they will have to pay ordinary income tax on the amounts distributed. Hence the "double" tax.

Estate have to pay tax on any amount above the exclusion, but heirs have to pay ordinary income tax on Required Minimum Distributions from an inherited IRA. There might be a way out of this double tax.

It could happen, and you should be aware of it if you happen to be in that position. You should also be wary of any financial professional who claims you can avoid the double tax by simply taking your money out of the IRA. Typically this pitch is designed to sell you an immediate annuity or some other form of annuity product. Pulling the money out of the IRA does nothing to eliminate the double tax, though.

In fact, what this does is accelerate the process and cause you to pay one part of the distribution -- the ordinary income tax -- upfront. Plus, this is usually pitched as a lump sum maneuver, which increases your taxable income and thereby the rate at which your distribution is taxed, among other things. Clearly, if someone tells you pulling all your money out of your IRA will avoid the double tax situation, you should walk away and don't look back.

Instead, if this double tax is a concern -- that is, if your estate is large enough to be affected -- it makes sense to review the entire potential estate and consider planning your distributions to your heirs. A gifting plan, along with appropriate trust mechanisms, can possibly reduce your gross estate below the exclusion level. This could have the effect of eliminating double taxation issues in advance and is truly the only way to possibly avoid the dreaded double tax.

This year and next
As the law is written, this year the estate tax exclusion is $5 million and step-up of basis is back in force. Again, if the funds are in an IRA, there is no step-up, although the basis of after-tax contributions and rollovers remains intact.

So if your estate has the opportunity to be greater than $5 million in value, any amounts above that exclusion amount will be subject to the estate tax. If those assets that are above the exclusion amount include your IRA or other retirement plans, your heirs will also have to pay ordinary income tax on the distributions -- effectively paying tax again on the same money, the double tax.

After 2012, the law is set to return to the $1 million estate tax exclusion, so we'll see what happens at that point.

Income in Respect of a Decedent
One way your heirs can avoid some of the double taxation is to use Income in Respect of a Decedent rules, which essentially allows the heir to claim a deduction of any income taxed by the estate tax. It gets complicated, but if you keep good records and pay attention as you file your returns, some of the double taxation is eliminated.


This commentary comes from an independent investor or market observer as part of TheStreet guest contributor program. The views expressed are those of the author and do not necessarily represent the views of TheStreet or its management.

If you liked this article you might like

Law Must Be With Google in Java Dispute

When to File for Social Security Benefits

When to File for Social Security Benefits

New Rules of Charity From Your IRA

Delay Social Security, Increase Your Benefits