Verizon 4G Flaws Call for Industry Gut Check

NEW YORK ( TheStreet) -- As part of the aggressive rollout of its blazingly fast 4G LTE network, Verizon ( VZ) has quietly remade the software consumers must use to access this network. Called VZAccess Manager, the application, which is similar to what AT&T ( T), Sprint ( S) and T-Mobile offer, brokers the connection between a Web modem plugged into a laptop and the cell networks providing that modem entry to the Internet.

But unlike most competitors, this most recent riff on VZAccess Manager offers remarkably accurate real-time upload and download speeds of actual network performance. In other words, you can really see -- minute by minute, bit by bit -- what kind of data service Verizon provides.

Verizon's rollout of the blazingly fast 4G LTE network through 2013 threatens to surpass its Apple iPhone launch in hype, but the promise of the network wasn't evident in a recent 750-plus mile test around the Northeast.

Dying to know what small businesses might expect for their cellular modem dollar, I took a Verizon LTE modem, a Sierra Wireless ( SWIR) 3G/4G wireless hotspot from Sprint and an HSPA+ modem from T-Mobile on a 750-some-odd mile cellular road trip to Maine and back.

As an unabashed tech geek who has dreamed of what truly fast wireless access could do to this economy, I'm sorry to report I have not spent a more depressing 12 hours in recent memory.

One G too far
For sure, one trip does not national coverage make. My colleagues and I will continue to test these tools across the country in the coming months to get a clearer networking picture. But my cellular test route from suburban Westchester County in New York up to Hartford, Conn., Boston and New Hampshire and then into Maine has been a reliable predictor of cellular performance for about 15 years. And I can't see how that would change merely because carriers are rolling out a faster service.

My initial takeaway? Sure, when there was 4G LTE access, it was impressive. In the few spots in and around New York and outside Boston -- remember full national rollout will not happen until 2013 -- LTE remains the benchmark for network speed and power.

But beyond that, I was stunned -- I mean stunned -- to see how feeble overall data rates were, even when there was nominally good so-called 3G digital coverage.

Now forget speeds that I might see from the Web connection in my office. I regularly saw 70 kilobits per second, or not much faster than the data rates provided by 56-baud modems from decades past. And often -- I mean like every 30 seconds in spots -- data rates would cycle down to nothing. Like Nada. Zero. Zip.

There often was no connectivity at all.

If you liked this article you might like

Comcast Dodges Big Social, Moves Watchable In-House

T-Mobile-Sprint Merger's First Big Challenge: Who Will Control It?

A Sprint/T-Mobile Deal Still Faces Big Hurdles, Especially for Sprint

Wall Street Overlooks Trump's North Korea Threats to Hit New Records

Cramer: Under Trump, These Are Probably Done Deals