By Technology Research Group eBay's ( EBAY) 10-K filing did little to change our bearish stance.

Revenue growth is slowing (2% vs. 11% in 2008). Margins are getting pinched. Cost-containment measures are readily apparent. Financial reporting remains far from conservative. Profits for 2009 were inflated by a series of income-accelerating items. Without these non-operational gains, net income would come in nearly 70% below reported levels.

Recurring restructuring charges, liberal use of discretionary expense accruals and weak revenue deferrals round out a list of earnings management concerns. Providing guidance in pro forma terms aggravates matters. Key takeaways can be summarized as follows:
  • Normalizing expense capitalization, valuation allowances (as a percentage of asset balance), NOL utilization, restructuring reserves, one-time gains and deferred revenue would pull EPS down to 56 cents for the year (vs. $1.83 as reported).
  • Return on equity falls to 5.4% (vs. 17.3% as reported) in sustainable operating terms.
  • Cash flow is up only 1% for the year and highly uncorrelated with net income.
  • Expense accruals jumped to $982 million (27% of current liabilities) from $785 million (17.4%) in 2008; usage conservative in absolute terms; direction of change worth noting; magnifies cash flow deceleration.
  • .
  • Consensus estimate for 2010 falls by 23% when measured on a fully expensed basis (GAAP estimate = $1.28 per share, pro forma = $1.67 per share).
  • Pro forma estimates overstate profitability and understate valuation multiples.

Valuation and Recommendation

Shares are up 93% over the past 12 months and valued at 13 times trailing GAAP earnings (note: valuation depressed by one-time gain in the fourth quarter of 2009; normalizing inverted EPS variance would put P/E right around 19). Comparable online marketplace provider ( AMZN) trades at roughly 58 times. Whether deserves such a lofty appraisal is open to debate. Earnings management is conservative. Operating trends are in much better shape. A fairly substantial premium would seem warranted. eBay's erratic financials should constrain upside. Downside volatility could be substantial. We reiterate a sell rating and $19 price objective. Target multiple moves to 12 times forward earnings from 14 times to reflect shift to pro forma estimates.

If you liked this article you might like

Former Macy's Herald Square Employees Sue Alleging Racial Profiling of Customers

Hewlett Packard Enterprise's Meg Whitman Joins Dropbox

EBay Is Breaking Out All Over

PayPal Owns a Millennial-Friendly Business That Might Send Its Stock Soaring

Jeff Immelt Out of Running for Uber CEO Position -- Here's Who Got the Gig