Is Warren Buffett Inspiring a Rail Bubble?

NEW YORK (TheStreet) -- The Warren Buffett bubble in railroads has burst twice already; is it going to be punctured again before year-end?

That is the question being posed by UBS Investment Research, and which led to a downgrade on Union Pacific ( UNP), judged by UBS the most expensive stock in the rail sector.

The rail industry has outperformed the S&P 500 by 10% since Berkshire Hathaway ( BRK.A) announced its acquisition of Burlington Northern ( BNI) on Nov. 3.

The two previous Buffet investments triggered a spike in rail shares , which in turn was shortly thereafter followed by the rail sector giving back half of those gains.

Let's take a look at the movement of the major North American railroad stocks versus the S&P in the weeks following the two previous big Berkshire Hathaway ( BRKA) sector plays.

The first bubble began in April 2007, after Berkshire Hathaway revealed that it had amassed an initial 10.9% interest in Burlington. Burlington stock jumped 6.5%, and the rail sector went up 4% the day after the announcement. The rails proceeded to outperform the S&P 500 by 9.2% over the next 9 trading days.

However, on the subsequent eight trading days, the rail group underperformed the market by 4.2%.

What UBS analysts have dubbed the Buffet-inspired premium was in evidence again in October 2007.

Berkshire Hathaway filings showed that Buffet had taken his stake in Burlington above 15%. Again, Burlington shares rose 6% on the news, leading a same-day rail group rally of more than 5%, versus an S&P daily performance of 4.2%.

In an even more dramatic waning of euphoria, however, the rail group's outperformance last only one day, and the sector gave back 2.4% of those gains over the next week and a half.

The October 2007 bubble was smaller than original because the market had already digested Buffet's focus on the rail industry, and was skeptical about the potential for a full blown acquisition.smaller than the spike after Buffett's initial 10.9% investment in Burlington of April 2007."

Which brings us back to the original, provocative questioned posed by UBS: is the current Buffet-inspired bubble about to pop?

After Berkshire announced its intention to acquire 100% of Burlington on Nov. 3, the rail group (ex-BNI) same-day rally of 6% was just a warm-up for a two week rise of 16% and outperformance through Nov. 23 of close to 10%.

With Warren Buffet as stationmaster, is a rail disaster ahead, or is this all just a bunch of noise and it is full speed ahead for the sector?

Before answering this question, it might be a good idea to consider some of the reaction to the UBS analysis from institutional investors.

-- Reported by Eric Rosenbaum in New York.

RELATED STORIES:



Follow TheStreet.com on Twitter and become a fan on Facebook.

Copyright 2009 TheStreet.com Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

More from Stocks

Facebook's Price Target Is Raised Ahead of Second-Quarter Earnings

Facebook's Price Target Is Raised Ahead of Second-Quarter Earnings

Dow Tumbles as Trump Ramps Up Trade Fight With China

Dow Tumbles as Trump Ramps Up Trade Fight With China

How to Trade General Electric's Stock After Earnings for Superior Gains

How to Trade General Electric's Stock After Earnings for Superior Gains

Top Strategist Reveals the Stocks to Focus On For the Last Half of 2018

Top Strategist Reveals the Stocks to Focus On For the Last Half of 2018

Stocks Weaken as Trump's Fed Rate Comments Open New Front in Global Trade War

Stocks Weaken as Trump's Fed Rate Comments Open New Front in Global Trade War