4. Ruby Jewel Treats: If you're going to make one thing, but make it well, the ice cream sandwich is a great pick. This Pacific Northwest-based company takes a few simple concepts -- cookies, ice cream, farm-fresh local ingredients -- and pours them into deliciously complex little pucks. The lemon and honey in its Lemon Cookie with Honey Lavender sandwiches are all natural, as is the mint in the Dark Chocolate Cookie with Fresh Mint sandwiches and the pumpkin from its seasonal Ginger Cookie with Pumpkin. With a case of 22 small sandwiches going for $55 and 15 large sandwiches fetching $60, they're definitely not Klondike bars. Get the variety pack.