Updated from 3:13 p.m. EDT

Shares of fast-food companies and food producers tanked Tuesday as investors worried that a single case of mad cow disease in Canada would stop consumers from eating beef.

"The key is public perception," said Carl Sibilski, a restaurant analyst at Morningstar.

Although the health risk is probably quite small, Sibilski said, food companies could still suffer from bad publicity. Shares of McDonald's ( MCD) slid 6% Tuesday at $17, while Tyson Foods ( TSN), the biggest U.S. beef processor, skidded 5% at $8.99. Meanwhile, Wendy's ( WEN) was off by 6% at $28.63.

McDonald's only has about 2% exposure to Canada and its operations there are self-contained, according to Sibilski. "But that's not going to help them if the U.S. consumer stops eating beef" out of fear of getting sick.

Still, he added that McDonald's is in a better position than competitor Wendy's because McDonald's also has operations in Europe. "The U.S. is McDonald's largest and most profitable country but they are diversified," he said. "For a company like Wendy's, its operations are mostly in Canada and the U.S., so I'd expect a bigger impact at that firm if people become afraid of eating beef."

Canada's biggest beef-producing territory reported that a single cow in Fairview with mad cow disease was killed in January, but tests only confirmed the diagnosis Tuesday. Federal Agriculture Minister Lyle Vanclief said in a news conference earlier that only one cow has been affected and that the animal didn't go into the food chain. Scientists believe a link exists between eating affected meat and the disease Creutzfeldt-Jakob in humans.

The northern Alberta herd to which the animal belonged has been quarantined, Vanclief said, adding that it would be "depopulated once the necessary samples have been obtained." Test results on the herd could be completed in as little as 48 hours, according to U.S. Agriculture Department Undersecretary J.B. Penn.

If you liked this article you might like

Coming Week: Earnings Flood

Coming Week: Earnings Flood

Don't Write Off Inflation Threat

Don't Write Off Inflation Threat

No Quick Fix for Trade Gap

No Quick Fix for Trade Gap

Merrill's Doll Sees Stocks 'Muddling Through'

Merrill's Doll Sees Stocks 'Muddling Through'

Downhill From Profit Peak

Downhill From Profit Peak