NEW YORK (
) -- Coal doesn't know if it will vote for President Obama in November.
That's what the headline probably should have said, but the Republican National Committee's Wednesday
email blast made it appear that Democrats have scuffled to the sideline in supporting Obama for 2012.
"Democrat Gov. Earl Ray Tomblin
of West Virginia said he -- like Sen. Joe Manchin, (D., W.V.) -- does not know if he will vote for President Barack Obama or Republican Mitt Romney in the fall," said the email, which quoted a
Charleston Daily Mail
A second excerpt of the story quotes Tomblin criticizing Obama for making it his mission to drive the coal and energy industry in West Virginia out of business.
( PCX) and
Alpha Natural Resources
-- which all have major Appalachia coal mining operations in West Virginia -- each have seen shares shrink by 41.4%, 31.1% and 19.8% year to date, respectively, largely
due to incredibly cheap natural gas prices.
"We have a supply of natural gas that can last America nearly 100 years," Obama said during his January State of the Union address. "The development of natural gas will create jobs and power trucks and factories that are cleaner and cheaper, proving that we don't have to choose between our environment and our economy."
Politicians in West Virginia, fearful of what the rapidly sinking coal industry could mean to jobs in the state, are timid to endorse an energy policy that backs gradual transition by utility companies to the industry (natural gas) that's wrecking things.
"I suspect if natural gas prices are close to what they
currently are for one, two years more, you're going to start to see some
coal bankruptcies over there." said Mike Tian, an equity analyst who covers coal for Morningstar
Cheaper natural gas prices give utilities and other businesses an incentive to invest in the hydrocarbon gas mixture instead of coal. But for Democratic politicians in West Virginia it's an awkward high-wire act. On the one hand -- and why Tomblin and Manchin have avoided open endorsement of the president -- it may appear to voters there that Obama, who has endorsed an energy plan to shift to natural gas and away from dirty coal, is the perpetrator of a waning West Virginia industry. Conversely, Obama is the most important figure in the party and can offer future key endorsements to the two politicians.
The move could also be more symbolic in nature. Coal is to West Virginia what lobster is to Maine -- a stereotype almost universally recognized in the United States.
Bankruptcies, shuttered operations and layoffs would spell difficulty for other industries, like railroads, as well.
There are only two Class I railroads that serve West Virginia (
about 98% of the state's rail traffic is for coal.
West Virginia has the second-largest recoverable coal reserves in the United States, and those reserves provide CSX and Norfolk Southern huge chunks of revenue there.
Tomblin and Manchin could have defended the health of other industries that profit from coal production (the two did say Obama's policies would hurt West Virginia's "energy industry" on the whole), but they stuck with coal.
Which returns us to the Republican National Committee's email to highlight two West Virginia Democrats who don't know if they will vote for Obama in November.
It's true that they haven't committed to him, but not all Democrats are the same. It would be politically advantageous for Democrats in Texas and Louisiana -- states that produce the most natural gas -- to endorse Obama and his energy policies as continued nat gas production would ensure economic growth and more jobs in those areas.
But it would be unwise to endorse Obama as West Virginians grapple with a new reality, where coal companies struggle and locals lose jobs that their families have held for generations.
"It's pretty grim, I would say," said Tian.
-- Written by Joe Deaux in New York.