Skip to main content

Fidelity Managers Ranked by Returns and Then Some

A Fidelity-watching newsletter attempts to identify the best stock pickers, not just those lucky enough to be in hot sectors.

Buy the manager, not the fund.

How many times have you heard that? But try to figure out the relative merit of managers in a big investment company who have jumped among several mutual funds in different market conditions over a period of years.

Fidelity Investor

, an independent newsletter that tracks

Fidelity

funds, is taking a shot at it with a system that ranks 29 general equity, 24 sector and 12 international managers. The cream of its crop: Charles Mangum of

(FDGFX) - Get Fidelity Dividend Growth Report

Dividend Growth for general equity funds, Yolanda McGettigan of

(FSHOX) - Get Fidelity Select Const & Housing Report

Select Construction and Housing for sector funds and Kenichi Mizushita of

(FJSCX) - Get Fidelity Japan Smaller Companies Report

Japan Small Companies for international funds.

The irony of the list is that it won't necessarily lead you to funds that even

Fidelity Investor

editor James Lowell would recommend. A terrific sector fund manager investing in a down-and-out industry doesn't make sense. Ditto for funds investing in specific areas of the world. It's not even a sure thing among general equity funds:

Fidelity Investor

Scroll to Continue

TheStreet Recommends

maintains a sell recommendation on Fidelity

(FFTYX)

Fifty, managed by its No. 2-rated manager, John Muresianu.

So the rankings have limitations, even if you accept them at face value. But we have a hard time resisting a list that tries to rate managers based on more than just their funds' percentage returns.

The

Fidelity Investor

list measures risk-adjusted relative performance, blending results for the last three years with performance over an entire career. In the end the calculations generate a number, representing the annual outperformance or underperformance of a manager.

Younger managers have a better opportunity to shoot to the top or sink like a rock because their three-year performances and lifetime returns are more or less the same thing. But fewer young managers than you might think made it to the top of the general equity rankings.

In most cases,

Fidelity Investor

selected different benchmarks than those used by Fidelity itself to generate a relative performance figure. For example, it uses the

Wilshire 5000

, not the

S&P 500

, to measure performance at

(FMAGX) - Get Fidelity Magellan Report

Magellan. And Rich Fentin's performance at Fidelity

(FDVLX) - Get Fidelity Value Report

Value was measured by two different

Barra

value stock indices, representing different blends of mid- and large-cap equities.

Alternative benchmarks became even more important in sector funds. For example, the most popular automotive stock indices give U.S. car makers as much as an 80% weighting. But Fidelity

(FSAVX) - Get Fidelity Select Automotive Report

Select Automotive and most other funds investing in the industry put most of their money in parts companies.

Mangum was a surprisingly easy winner in the general equity group. Dividend Growth is coming off a terrific 1998, when it earned 35.9%. But Mangum also racked up big points under the

Fidelity Investor

system when he managed two Fidelity Select funds,

(FSPHX) - Get Fidelity Select Health Care Report

Health Care and

(FSHCX) - Get Fidelity Select Health Care Svcs Report

Medical Delivery, in the early to mid-1990s. He suffered modestly negative numbers running Fidelity's

(FCVSX) - Get Fidelity Convertible Securities Report

Convertible Securities fund in 1995 and

(FOCPX) - Get Fidelity OTC Portfolio Report

OTC in 1996.

Muresianu is easily the biggest surprise on this list. Muresianu has spent his Fidelity mutual fund career running utility sector funds, and he hadn't even been doing that for a year when he was named the new manager of Fidelity Fifty earlier this month.

Whether credentials as a good utility investor mean a manager will do well running a concentrated general stock portfolio remains to be seen. But

Fidelity Investor

maintains its sell recommendation on the fund, mostly because Lowell doesn't care for concept funds and distinctly dislikes this one (investing in top 50 stock ideas, an idea from which Fidelity Fifty managers have often strayed).

"I wouldn't be rushing out to buy Fifty just because he's on board," said Lowell. "But it's probably the first time I'll pay some attention to it."

Muresianu has turned in some eye-catching numbers at Fidelity Fifty, already gaining 7.7% for the year to date through last week. Another Fidelity watcher, Eric Kobren of

Fidelity Insight

, believes the fund soared because it had moved about 20% of the portfolio into Internet-related stocks. Fifty had actually bolted out of the gate this year with returns of more than 15% in early January but has since settled back down as Internet stocks cooled a bit.

The older Fidelity veterans tended to hold their own. Magellan's Bob Stansky ranked fourth on the general equity list.

(FCNTX) - Get Fidelity Contrafund Report

Contrafund's Will Danoff was eighth, ahead of

(FDESX) - Get Fidelity Adv Diversified Stock O Report

Destiny's George Vanderheiden (12th) and Fidelity

(FFIDX) - Get Fidelity Fund Report

Fund's Beth Terrana (13th).

The biggest surprise near the bottom of the list: Value's Fentin, who finished 26th in the general equity field of 29 managers.

Overall, 14 of the 29 managers finished with a positive rating and one,

(FDGRX) - Get Fidelity Growth Company Report

Growth Company's Steven Wymer, just missed with a negative. That means about half of the managers outperformed the benchmarks

Fidelity Investor

selected for them. And batting .500 in this league makes you an all-star.

"You can say that Fidelity managers are significantly good at what they do," said Lowell. "Then there are the more problematic concerns that some managers bring to the table."

Steven Syre & Steve Bailey write for the

Boston Globe

. This column is exclusive to

TheStreet.com

. Under no circumstances does the information in this column represent a recommendation to buy stocks or funds.