Skip to main content



) -- With four days left before the federal government heads over the so-called fiscal cliff and new reports that the U.S. Treasury may hit a 'debt ceiling' by the New Year, investors have a lot to worry about.

Lingering outside the daily political ping pong between Democrats and Republicans are Wall Street ratings agencies. As


(MCO) - Get Moody's Corporation Report


Standard & Poor's


Fitch Ratings

act as quiet bystanders to ongoing budget negotiations, investors may do well to consider them as a key risk factor as lawmakers either pull together a last-minute deal before the cliff deadline or allow the U.S. economy to hurdle over it.

Notably, Moody's, S&P and Fitch have spent recent months telegraphing to investors how they would react to a multitude of different budget scenario's. Interestingly, while heading over the cliff would appear to be the worst possible outcome for investors, ratings agencies outline why they think differently.

Moody's said in recent review of the U.S. government's debt rating that a last minute deal, which kicks the can down the road on revenue increases, spending cuts, or both, would be the worst possible outcome. Meanwhile, Fitch sees a negotiation that spills into 2013 as reason to reconsider the government's rating.

Unfortunately for investors both scenario's appear to be in the cards, given the limited amount of time Congress has to negotiate a so-called Grand Bargain this year.

On Thursday, Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid said it "looks like" Congress wouldn't be able to broker a cliff-avoiding deal by year-end. With House Majority leader John Boehner sidelines by a Republican congressional camp that couldn't approve his "Plan B" budget deal, the dimming prospect of a Senate leaves lawmakers with few options.

President Obama said on Dec. 21 that in the absence of a deal, Congress should at least put together a bill to maintain tax cuts on those earning less than $250,000 a year, while extending unemployment benefits for roughly 2 million workers.

TheStreet Recommends

According to rating agencies, heading over the fiscal cliff might have a similar impact for the U.S. government as a so-called Grand Bargain, which could capture the revenue increases Democrats are pining for and the spending cuts Republicans continue to hold out on.

Moody's said in September

it may downgrade

the U.S. debt rating from Aaa - its highest rating -- to Aa1 by 2014 if budget negotiations during the 2013 Congressional legislative session fail to stabilize the federal debt to GDP ratio. Currently, Moody's holds the U.S. government's Aaa rating with a "negative" outlook, signaling that a rating review would likely yield a cut.

Interestingly, Moody's sees the prospect of a ratings benefit if the U.S. were to fall off the fiscal cliff.


If the "fiscal cliff" strategy is adopted to achieve debt stabilization - involving a large, immediate fiscal shock that would improve government finances in the short term but likely result in recession and higher unemployment - we would maintain our Aaa rating with a negative outlook and await evidence that the economy could rebound before considering a return to a stable outlook," wrote Steven A. Hess and Bart Oosterveld of Moody's in a November reiteration of the agencies ratings review.

In contrast, were lawmakers to broker a fiscal cliff deal that kicks the can down the road on debt reduction without outlining specific budget stabilization plans, Moody's hints at a possible downgrade prior to 2014.

The opinions of ratings agencies matter for investors. When S&P cut the U.S. government's debt ratings from AAA in the wake of a last minute August 2011 deal to raise the government's debt limit and stave off a default, markets sold off sharply.

Fitch Ratings

, meanwhile, remains optimistic of a deal by year end and points political gridlock as reason to consider a downgrade of the U.S. government's debt rating. Were fiscal cliff negotiations to drag well into 2013, Fitch said earlier in December it could lead to a ratings cut. "

The U.S. sovereign rating could be subject to review, potentially leading to a negative rating action," in a protracted negotiation, Fitch said in a report earlier in December.

In September, independent ratings firm Egan Jones cut the U.S. government's debt rating one level to AA-, noting how the

Federal Reserve's

easing efforts may hit the U.S. dollar and drive up inflation. On Aug. 5, S&P was the first agency to cut the government's debt rating, lowering it to AA+ as a result of what's now known as a 'fiscal cliff' that falls short of what's needed to stabilize the government's medium-term debt issues.

As investors parse over an increasingly frenetic and hard to read dance between Democratic and Republican lawmakers, they should take note of ratings agencies, the silent arbiter of any prospective budget deal. While heading over the cliff may appear to be the worst possible outcome for investors, agencies see differently.

For more on the fiscal cliff, see why

a housing recovery could blunt a partisan standoff


-- Written by Antoine Gara in New York