Madoff's Closed-End Funds Sink

The alleged fraudster invested in some funds that lost more than half their value last year.
Publish date:

The case against Bernard Madoff is far from closed. But the alleged fraudster's closed-end fund holdings are open for public scrutiny.

The 13F filing for Bernard L. Madoff Investment Securities LLC dated Nov. 10 reveals positions in 17 closed-end funds (CEFs), mostly high-yield and senior bank-debt vehicles. Funds in these asset classes last year suffered awesome declines in the value of their underlying securities, or their net asset value (NAV).

Closed-end mutual funds are actively managed funds that raise capital by issuing a fixed number of shares. Like open-end mutual funds, managers buy and sell individual investments in line with their objectives. The shares are traded on an exchange, and prices fluctuate throughout the trading day, based on supply, demand and the changing values of the underlying holdings.

Some of the largest positions were in the

New American High Income Fund

(HYB) - Get Report

, down 39.9% in 2008;

BlackRock High Income Shares


, minus 36.8%;

ING Prime Rate Trust

(PPR) - Get Report

, down 42.4%;

Van Kampen Senior Income Trust

(VVR) - Get Report

, minus 58.8%; and

Eaton Vance Senior Income Trust

(EVF) - Get Report

, down 47.7%.

It is unknown if Madoff himself purchased the funds for his alleged Ponzi scheme or if they were owned by clients of his market-making brokerage firm. Nevertheless, since most of the CEFs were held for more than a year, Utah-based CEF specialist Art Lipson speculates they were Bernie's picks.

"They don't seem to be trading positions," says Lipson. "And, unfortunately, it was a tough year for those asset classes."

That could be changing, however, as the market for high-yield corporate bonds and so-called "spread products" continues to improve. Discounts for most of Madoff's CEFs have narrowed since last fall and NAVs have recovered considerably over the past week as investors moved away from Treasuries to accept more risk. The

iShares High Yield Corporate Bond Exchange Traded Fund

(HYG) - Get Report

, for example, rose nearly 5% on Monday after being boosted by a


article that was negative on Treasuries.

So maybe now is the time to follow Madoff's lead. Into beaten-down CEFs, not prison, of course.

Before joining, Gregg Greenberg was a writer and segment producer for CNBC's Closing Bell. He previously worked at FleetBoston and Lehman Brothers in their Private Client Services divisions, covering high net-worth individuals and midsize hedge funds. Greenberg attended New York University's School of Business and Economic Reporting. He also has an M.B.A. from Cornell University's Johnson School of Business, and a B.A. in history from Amherst College.