Black Friday Winners & Losers: Best Buy

Black Friday reveals potential winners and losers of the holiday season.
Publish date:



) -- While

Black Friday shouldn't be used as the sole gauge of the health of the holidays

, it has revealed some possible winners and losers for the season.

Unsurprisingly, electronics were the most popular purchases last weekend, specifically flat-panel televisions.

"Despite the media hype surrounding Black Friday, the weekend is critical to the holiday season only for one major merchandise category -- consumer electronics -- which will see some 20% of Christmas sales over the three-day weekend," Craig Johnson, president at Customer Growth Partners, said in a statement.

Deep discounts lured shoppers to


(WMT) - Get Report

, but

Best Buy

(BBY) - Get Report

was one of the highly talked about standouts.

In its first Black Friday without direct competition from Circuit City, Best Buy saw 25% of shoppers who purchased a TV buy it at its stores, according to UBS. This compares to half of shoppers who bought their TV at Wal-Mart.

"If you consider how many more stores Wal-Mart has compared with Best Buy, this is a good showing," UBS analysts said during a conference call.

Best Buy also reigned supreme in the home appliances category, a sector starting to show signs of a recovery, Johnson wrote.




achieved some notoriety for sales of its washer-dryer pair, Best Buy stores reported selling its entire allotment of up to 80 washer-dryers by mid-afternoon on Black Friday, Johnson wrote.

J.P. Morgan analyst Christopher Horvers expects the electronics retailers to post a 5% jump in domestic same-store sales in the fourth quarter.



(AAPL) - Get Report

iPod is losing its hottest gift ranking, the electronic company saw remarkable success with its new iMacs and MacBooks, which Kaufman Bros. analyst Shaw Wu said are out of stock or limited.

Apple stores continued to be the go-to shopping destination over the weekend, he wrote in a note.

Several reports rank department stores and discounters neck-and-neck as the primary shopping destination Black Friday weekend. The National Retail Federation said nearly half of shoppers visited at least one department store, while 43.2% shopped at a discounter.

"Department stores have done an admirable job touting both low prices and good quality, which are important requirements for holiday shoppers on a budget," Tracy Mullen, NRF president and CEO said in a statement.

UBS analysts said

J.C. Penney

(JCP) - Get Report



(M) - Get Report

appeared to have the highest conversion rate in the sector.

Still, it looks like no matter how you twist it, Wal-Mart remains king, with 65% of those surveyed by America's Research Group, in conjunction with UBS, saying they shopped at the discount behemoth.

This year nearly all Wal-Mart stores were open on Thanksgiving Day (an attempt to avoid the deadly Black Friday stampede seen last year) and on Black Friday parking lots were jammed, with lines stretching around the store, UBS analysts observed.

Shopping carts were filled with a broad mix of products, with HP computers and pajama sets popular items.


(TGT) - Get Report

, however, is giving Wal-Mart a run for its money, as it boosts its value-message this year. The discounter was significantly busier this year compared with last year and stores opened at 5 a.m. rather than 6 a.m.

Compared to Wal-Mart, Target shopping carts had smaller-ticket items and it saw the most traffic in its consumers electronic and toy department.

Two teen retailers --

American Eagle Outfitters

(AEO) - Get Report


Abercrombie & Fitch

(ANF) - Get Report

-- were upgraded on Monday for their strong showing over the weekend.

American Eagle was lifted to buy from hold by Lazard Capital Markets. Sales have risen in the first three weeks of November, and analyst Todd Slater said there is a chance the teen retailer will post better-than-expected fourth-quarter results due to a successful Black Friday and strong November sales.

Friedman, Billings, Ramsey analyst Adrienne Tennant upgraded Abercrombie to outperform from market perform as traffic improves at its Hollister chain.

Over the weekend, Hollister offered deep promotions on tops (buy one get one 50% off), denim (40% off), T-shirts and hoodies.

Tennant also booster her price target to $46 from $39.

Despite refraining from Black Friday promotions,

Urban Outfitter's

(URBN) - Get Report

Anthropologie and



were still bustling with shoppers. "To me, this is a better indicator of long-term sustainability than seen from discounts," UBS analyst Roxanne Meyer said during a conference call.


(GPS) - Get Report

Old Navy chain and



were also some of the more crowded stores in the mall.

While apparel is slowly making a comeback, missy stores lagged the sector, as department stores offered more compelling promotions.


(CHS) - Get Report

ran a 20% discount, while

Coldwater Creek


was offering a 25% off sale.

Within women's apparel

AnnTaylor Stores


showed the most promise, as it stole market share with its 40% off early bird special, Meyer said.

As expected, sales at luxury retailers were slow. Generally luxury sales are concentrated in the last 10 days before Christmas, particularly for jewelry and watches.



factory store, however, was the exception.

According to UBS, 300 people were in-line at a factory store they visited, and lines lasted several hours with shoppers purchasing multiple items.

Video games were also one of the biggest disappointments, Horvers wrote in a note.


(GME) - Get Report

received a boost from the launch of

Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2

earlier in the month, but this hype is fading, and consumers are turning to discounters for video game value bundles.

"If you are a video game publisher and do not have a top-tier title in the market, it's going to be a challenging holiday quarter," Brian Sozzi, analyst at Wall Street Strategies, wrote in a note. He said he is starting to see discounts pop up across the board on video games, as well as some stronger promotions on some of the leading "triple A" titles.

-- Reported by Jeanine Poggi in New York

Follow on


and become a fan on


Copyright 2009 Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.