AIG's Benmosche Stands His Ground: Today's Outrage

AIG CEO Robert Benmosche is taking a stand against meddling by the Obama administration. He might be right, but he won't win this fight.
Publish date:



) --


(AIG) - Get Report

CEO Robert Benmosche has had it with

government interference


Word on the street is that after just three months on the job, Benmosche is threatening to walk away from AIG because of the shackles placed on him by the Obama administration, in particular the compensation constraints. Confidants say Benmosche feels he is in an "impossible situation" according to the

Wall Street Journal


Sounds to me like Benmosche and outgoing

Bank of America

(BAC) - Get Report

CEO Ken Lewis have a lot in common. Note to Benmosche: Lewis lost his battle with Obama.

Benmosche's level of frustration and threat to leave should come as no surprise. He demanded more independence and took a stand on pay issues from the very beginning. In his first month on the job, he reportedly got a

stern warning from the AIG board

to tone down his tough talk about keeping compensation competitive.

In the end, Benmosche was granted approval for his own

$10.5 million pay package

, split between $3 million in cash, $4 million in stock and as much as $3.5 million a year as part of a stock incentive plan. Under the terms of the government's approval, he doesn't get any kind of severance.

This whole compensation debate is fraught with peril because banking salaries and bonuses seem so out of whack with the incomes of ordinary Americans, creating wonderful opportunities for political grandstanding.

While we are a nation founded on the ideal of endless opportunity for those with the gumption to pursue it, that only applies when you succeed on your own.

When trillions of dollars in taxpayer money is used to prop up the financial sector because of a massive self-inflicted crisis, then it's easy to argue that the bankers and insurers haven't earned the money they've grown accustomed to being paid. So on behalf of the people, the government is now challenging the compensation structure.

AIG is in a particularly weak position to demand independence since it is the poster child for the bailout and is now owned 80% by taxpayers. Without the bailout, AIG would be dead.

That said, I applaud Benmosche for taking a stand. Free markets and capitalism are also fundamental to the American way of life. We don't like massive government intervention in our private business affairs. We've never believed in socialist-style government ownership of private enterprise.

Benmosche just seems to want the government to start acting more like a shareholder and less like his boss. I haven't heard him say he wants to dole out

massive bonuses


Goldman Sachs

(GS) - Get Report


Morgan Stanley

(MS) - Get Report


JPMorgan Chase

(JPM) - Get Report


As far as I can tell, he just wants to be treated like a CEO instead of a government lackey. He wants the freedom to run AIG and fix the mess.

That's not likely any time soon. The Obama administration is clinging to the emergency powers it gained through the bailout and is imposing martial law on business rather than regulating and getting out of the way.

At some point, Washington's meddling needs to stop. In the meantime, Benmosche isn't likely to win this fight.

--Written by Glenn Hall in New York.

Get TheStreet on your Kindle

or follow on


and become a fan on


Glenn Hall is the New York-based Editor in Chief of

. Previously, he served as deputy editor and chief innovation officer at

The Orange County Register

and as a news manager at

Bloomberg News

in Frankfurt, Amsterdam and Washington, D.C. As a reporter, he covered business and financial markets, worked in both print and television in the U.S. and Europe, and conducted in-depth investigative coverage at

The Journal-Gazette

in Fort Wayne, Ind. His work also has been published in a variety of newspapers including

The Wall Street Journal


The New York Times


International Herald Tribune

. Hall received a bachelor's degree in journalism and political science from The Ohio State University and a certificate in project and program management from Boston University.