Skip to main content

Stocks Off Their Mortgage-Bailout Highs

The Dow and S&P have edged off their early highs but still trade steeply positive. The Nasdaq takes a dip lower.

Updated from 12:28 p.m. EDT

Blue-chip stocks were off their highs but still sharply positive Monday after the U.S. government said it would take over mortgage giants

Fannie Mae



Freddie Mac


. Technology shares, however, were dipping into the red.


Dow Jones Industrial Average

was up 174 points to 11,395, and the

S&P 500

was gaining 13 points at 1256. The


was down 6 points to 2250.

On Sunday, the Treasury Department and Federal Housing Finance Agency said they would temporarily seize

Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac

, replacing the mortgage giants' CEOs, buying preferred shares of the companies and offering additional capital support as Fannie and Freddie wade through increasing home-buyer defaults.

The two government-sponsored entities -- which have issued more than $5 trillion in mortgage-backed securities and credit -- are central to the health of the U.S. home-lending market and are lynchpins of the financial sector. Investment bank

Morgan Stanley

(MS) - Get Free Report

aided the government in its takeover of the firms.

Although news of their takeover was buoying the blue-chip indices, shares of Fannie and Freddie were getting destroyed, down 87% and 82%, respectively. Citigroup downgraded the stocks to sell from buy, and Lehman revised its rating on the pair to equal weight from overweight.

"I don't think it's a sucker's rally," said Marc Pado, U.S. market strategist at Cantor Fitzgerald. The takeover was necessary, he said. "Yeah, it's not going to end the crisis, but it's a step in the direction of ending it," he said. Although Pado believes the government should have acted sooner, he said the takeover has restored confidence to the market.

Providing capital to Fannie and Freddie was the most important step the Treasury and FHFA took. "Making sure that that capital is available and keeping the entities functioning is what the market needed," he said.

The takeover relieves some of the market's concern about the credit crisis and housing market, said Robert Pavlik, chief investment officer at Oaktree Asset Management. "However, I think it's going to take additional time before those concerns are fully resolved," Pavlik said. He expects stocks to get a short-term bounce on the takeover until the market redirects its attention to the global economic slowdown.

"There are still problems out there. Lending standards are still going to be high. Banks' balance sheets are still going to be screwy," said Pavlik. He predicts that high inflation and a weak labor market and high consumer debt will continue to hinder the economy. "Are people going to be able to refinance their homes to pay their credit cards and buy new cars? The answer's no," he said.

Pavlik said that the rally in the financial sector needs to be accompanied by substantial volume and solid breadth: "You could say there's a lot of cash sitting on the sidelines, but I think it's a lot of smart money that won't necessarily get drawn into a bounce in the market." He said that

Goldman Sachs'

(GS) - Get Free Report

quarterly earnings, due next week, could let a lot of air out of the sector's rally.

From the taxpayer's perspective, the takeover is an open commitment, said Dan Seivers, professor of finance at San Diego State University. "

The government's long-term fiscal is getting pretty bad. We have huge budget deficits in the long run, and this will potentially make that worse."

The benefit of the bailout, said Seivers, is that mortgage rates are likely to decline slightly. He said that the government-sponsored entities business model, which privatized gains and left taxpayers on the hook for losses, was seriously flawed and now will be changed. He said a takeover was inevitable. "We avoided disaster, and I think that's always a good policy," he said.

In other company news, struggling brokerage

Lehman Brothers


announced over the weekend that it would replace two members of senior management as it prepares to lay off between 1,000 and 1,500 employees.

The Wall Street Journal

also reported that


(WM) - Get Free Report

(WB) - Get Free Report

is looking to

take David Zwiener of the Carlyle Group

as its new chief financial officer.

Elsewhere in the financials,

Washington Mutual

(WM) - Get Free Report

announced a shakeup in its top brass.

CEO Kerry Killinger

, who oversaw $19 billion in mortgage-related writedowns during his tenure, is stepping down. Alan Fishman, chair of Meridian Capital and president of

Sovereign Bancorp


will take over the chief executive spot.

Financial names and homebuilding stocks were among the biggest gainers. The

Financial Select Sector SPDR

(XLF) - Get Free Report

, which tracks the financial-services group, was up 2.3%. Homebuilding names were also broadly rising. The

SPDR S&P Homebuilders

(XHB) - Get Free Report

jumped 8.1%.

Cigarette maker


(MO) - Get Free Report

said it would buy chewing-tobacco producer


(UST) - Get Free Report

for about $10 billion in cash.

United Airlines


shares fell to $3 after a news outlet accidentally posted on its Web site an outdated report that the

airline was filing for bankruptcy , according to a report by


. After a brief halt of trading, shares were recently down 8%.

Looking at the day's economic data, the

Federal Reserve's

measure of July consumer debt is expected to be released this afternoon.

As for commodities, the price of crude oil was down 57 cents at $105.66. Gold gained $1.50 to $804.30.

Longer-dated U.S. Treasury securities were mixed. The 10-year was down 2/32 to yield 3.71%. The 30-year was up 4/32, yielding 4.29%. The dollar was gaining on the euro, yen and pound.

Overseas exchanges, including the FTSE in London, the Dax in Frankfurt, the Nikkei in Japan and the Hang Seng in Hong Kong, were making substantial gains.