Skip to main content

Stocks Lock In Gains

The bulls take the win on Wall Street as buyers emerged after the Department of Commerce reported GDP declined in the third quarter but not by as much as expected. Frank Curzio reviews the day's action in The Real Story (above).
  • Author:
  • Publish date:

Updated from 2:53 p.m. EDT

Following a day marked by choppy but mostly positive trading, U.S. stocks finished Thursday on the upside, as a decline in third-quarter GDP was narrower than expected and companies issued a heap of

quarterly earnings



Dow Jones Industrial Average

climbed 189.73 points, or 2.1%, to 9180.69, and the

S&P 500

added 24 points, or 2.6%, to 954.09. The


jumped 41.31 points, or 2.5%, to 1698.52.

Ahead of Thursday's session, the Department of Commerce reported that

GDP contracted 0.3%

in the third quarter, providing a strong indication that the U.S. has entered a recession. The decline was narrower than expected by economists but down from growth of 2.8% in the second quarter. Consumer spending for the third quarter was down 3.1%, the biggest drop since 1980.

Separately, the Department of Labor's initial jobless claims for the week ended Oct. 25 registered at 479,000, above analyst estimates and level with the previous week.

"If you'd been wondering if there was recession, this kind of brings it home," said Phil Dow, director of equity strategy at RBC Dain Rauscher. He said that historically, a recession has been ongoing by the time the government says there is one, and that he thinks going forward the U.S. will see a two-quarter recession followed by modest growth.

"We shouldn't look for perfection in these estimates," said Dow. "It's pretty easy to get in a black mood and think that this is going to extend forever."

Image placeholder title

As for the GDP number's impact on stocks, "Normally you have the stock market recover even when it's cloudy," said Dow, and he said the market feels like it's close to an interesting bottom in pricing.

Steven Wieting, economist at Citigroup, wrote in an email that declines in production and employment, coupled with tight credit markets and wealth destruction indicate that GDP may decline more than 3% for the fourth quarter.

However, "Assuming some easing in extraordinarily tight credit markets, we may currently be experiencing the worst pace of contraction in domestic economic activity overall," he wrote.

On the other hand, Bill Fleckenstein, hedge fund manager for Fleckenstein Capital, said he expects to see a sustained contraction, because many companies have said that business has dropped off significantly. "The psychological sea change that's taking place isn't being captured by these numbers. ... We are going to have a brutal recession. That cannot be changed."

In terms of government intervention, "From a balance-sheet standpoint, the country's kind of broke," said Fleckenstein. He said that continued efforts to prop up housing prices is a failing undertaking, and that, given a limited set of options, the government would be better served funding infrastructure and energy projects to alleviate unemployment and reinvigorate the economy.

Additional government efforts to bolster the economy looked to be in the works, as


reported that the Treasury Department and the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. may devote $500 billion to help avert home foreclosures.

Image placeholder title

Meanwhile, in the wake of the

Federal Reserve's

50-basis-point rate cut that brought its target interest rate to 1% Wednesday, debt markets were relaxing. Three-month dollar Libor was down 23 basis points to 3.19%, and overnight Libor declined 41 basis points to 0.73%.

Several companies were tightening their belts ahead of a tough 2009.

American Express

(AXP) - Get Free Report

announced it would cut jobs and reduce compensation in an effort to save $1.8 billion in costs for 2009. Shares ticked up 3.4% to $26.06.

The Wall Street Journal

also reported on its Web site that



would lay off 3,000 workers, with two-thirds of the cuts coming from the cell phone division. The report emerged after


swung to a third-quarter loss and offered lower guidance for the year. The stock dropped 5% to $5.19.

Analyst actions

illustrated uncertainty about the future of the banking sector. Merrill Lynch reduced 2009 earnings estimates for

Goldman Sachs

(GS) - Get Free Report


Morgan Stanley

(MS) - Get Free Report

further below consensus, while raising estimates for


(C) - Get Free Report


JPMorgan Chase

(JPM) - Get Free Report

further above consensus.

Goldman shares slipped 6.7% to $91.11, Morgan Stanley climbed 9% to $16.09, Citi shares added 2.8% to $13.11 and JPMorgan climbed 5.4% to $37.62.

A smattering of corporate earnings were once again occupying traders' attention. Following Wednesday's close, insurance company


(MET) - Get Free Report

announced a decline in quarterly profit. Fellow insurer


(PRU) - Get Free Report

swung to a loss. MetLife edged 2.2% higher to $30.20, while Prudential plummeted 18% to $28.87.

Also hit hard among insurers was


(HIG) - Get Free Report

, which lost $2.6 billion in the third quarter and cut its full-year guidance. Shares sank 52% to $10.24.

Image placeholder title

Investors heard from a variety of energy companies. Integrated oil firm and Dow component

Exxon Mobil

(XOM) - Get Free Report

posted earnings of $14.8 billion, the largest quarterly profit ever reported by a U.S. company. The stock tacked on 0.5% to $75.05.

Royal Dutch Shell


reported income that rose 71% year over year on higher oil prices, but shares slumped 3.1% to $54.10. Oil and natural gas firm


(APA) - Get Free Report

reported a profit for the third quarter that increased 94% from the year-ago period. The stock jumped 5.5% to $78.95.

Murphy Oil

(MUR) - Get Free Report

, on the other hand, reported a substantial increase in third-quarter earnings but lowered guidance for the fourth quarter. Shares gained 4.9% to $49.61.

Telecommunications equipment maker



reported a loss on falling revenue and charges stemming from the merger between Alcatel and Lucent. The stock rocketed 9.5% to $2.53.

Elsewhere, pharmaceutical company


(AZN) - Get Free Report

reported net income that rose year over year. Consumer products maker


(CL) - Get Free Report

also announced an increase in profit on rising sales. AstraZeneca rose 6.9% to $42.49, and Colgate-Palmolive jumped 7.1% to $64.23.

On the merger front,

Delta Air Lines

(DAL) - Get Free Report

completed its acquisition of

Northwest Airlines


. Delta shares soared 20% to $9.55.

Crude oil lost $1.54 to settle at $65.96 a barrel. Gold shed $15.50 to close at $738.50 an ounce.

Longer-dated U.S. Treasury securities were falling in price. The 10-year note was down 24/32 to yield 3.94%, and the 30-year was declining 32/32, yielding 4.3%. The dollar was rising vs. the yen, but falling against the euro and pound.

Overseas, European exchanges including the FTSE in London and the Dax in Frankfurt were trading higher. In


, Japan's Nikkei and Hong Kong's Hang Seng closed with substantial gains.


Photo gallery: Trading Faces