Stocks Trade Even on Latest Economic Data

The major indices are bobbing around the baseline on new housing and consumer sentiment data as well as a fresh slate of earnings.
Publish date:

Updated from 11:05 a.m. EDT

Stocks in New York struggled for direction Friday, even after the release of discouraging housing data and a record low in a consumer sentiment survey.


Dow Jones Industrial Average

was lately down 20 points at 8958, while the the

S&P 500

was tackign on 2 points to 948. The


was up 5.8 points at 1723.

The day's economic data looked bearish. The Census Bureau reported that September building permits came in at an annualized rate of 786,000, down from 857,000 in August and below analyst estimates. New-home starts were estimated at 817,000, hitting a 17-year low.

Michael Pento, senior market strategist at Delta Global Advisors, said that the U.S. needs to build 1.15 million units a year to satisfy the needs of Americans. "We're building significantly below that at this time," he said.

Pento also said that the U.S. has excessive housing inventory, and housing starts may have to drop to 500,000 to clear out the excess. He said that historically, 64% of the U.S. population owned homes, and lately the number has increased to 67.8%. The ratio of median home price to median income has risen to 4-to-1, vs. historical levels of 3-to-1, he said. "You have to wash out all those people who have no business owning a house, people that should be renters," he said. "Simple back of the envelope, you need a 25% drop in home prices just to get to historical measures."

He said the government's monetary policy has been an attempt to bring incomes up to levels where people can afford their homes. "That's a very scary way to solve the problem," he said.

In terms of the stock market, recent volatility illustrates that it's near impossible to time a bottom in this environment, said Bill Stone, chief investment strategist at PNC Wealth Management. "You have to either come in and say, 'I find value or don't find value in stocks,'" he said. Stone said he sees value in health care, consumer staples and some tech stocks.

"If your call is depression, then no, it's not priced in," said Stone, but "it's pretty grim what's priced in now." He said that recent economic data has often been worse than expected, but expectations have been substantially lowered of late. "I would say even less-negative data would be looked upon favorably."

Stone said that eventually the housing market will clear the inventory, but building permits have farther to fall.

Outside of the housing market, an October consumer sentiment reading from the University of Michigan showed a drop to 57.5 from 70.3 in September, the index's largest decline on record.

Credit markets continued to loosen slightly, as three-month dollar Libor, a measure of the rate banks charge one another for large loans, dropped 8 basis points to 4.42%. Overnight Libor was lower by 27 basis points to 1.67%.

Pento said he wishes the credit markets wouldn't heal very fast. "They really need to be blown out. Banks need to stop loaning money to each other ... so the consumer can deleverage their balance sheet." He said that the government's injection of capital into the markets is preventing a necessary deleveraging process. "I think the government is going to be successful in forcing banks to lend to a consumer that is choking on debt," he said.

On the other hand, said Stone of PNC Wealth Management, lending standards continue to tighten, and that barring a government mandate, it's hard to believe that those standards will be greatly reduced. Currently, it's hard for even people with good credit to get a loan, he said.

Billionaire investor Warren Buffett, CEO of

Berkshire Hathaway

(BRK.A) - Get Report

advocated buying stocks in an op-ed published by

The New York Times

. Buffett said that the economy faces hardship in the near term, and for that reason he has placed a large portion of his investment portfolio into U.S. stocks.

Trouble in the financials persisted ahead of Friday's session. Bond insurer



, along with some of its competitors, was working to petition the Treasury Department so that it could sell troubled assets to the government, according to a report by




also reported that the New York

Federal Reserve

was in talks to create a clearinghouse for the $55 trillion credit default swaps market.



season hit full stride,

Capital One

(COF) - Get Report

posted a third-quarter profit that missed analysts' expectations.

Earnings from the tech sector also were in the spotlight.


(IBM) - Get Report

said it would meet full-year estimates after reporting increased third-quarter profit on cost reductions and strong international sales.

Meanwhile, Internet search firm


(GOOG) - Get Report

beat estimates for the third quarter and said that its business could withstand a recession.

Sony Ericsson

, a joint venture between


(SNE) - Get Report



(ERIC) - Get Report

, reported a third-quarter loss on restructuring charges.

Defense firm


(HON) - Get Report

saw income rise year over year and beat analyst estimates.

Oil-services company


(SLB) - Get Report

announced rising profit on a substantial increase in revenue.

Beyond earnings,

The Wall Street Journal

reported that

General Motors

(GM) - Get Report

was ramping up merger discussions with




(F) - Get Report

plans on selling shares in


to Japanese firms, according to a report in


that cited local media.

In the pharmaceutical space,


(PFE) - Get Report

agreed to pay $894 million to settle legal claims related to adverse effects of its

Celebrex and Bextra


As for commodities, crude oil was up $1.74 to $71.59 a barrel. Gold was down $21.50 to $783 an ounce.

Longer-dated U.S. Treasury securities were mixed. The 10-year was up 2/32 to yield 3.96%, and the 30-year was shedding 14/32, yielding 4.28%. The dollar was higher vs. the yen, but weakening against the euro and pound.

Abroad, European exchanges were edging higher. The FTSE in London and the Dax in Frankfurt were both trading with gains. Looking at

Asian stocks

, Japan's Nikkei closed on the upside, while the Hang Seng in Hong Kong finished with losses.