Skip to main content

Tesla Inc (TSLA) - Get Tesla Inc Report has come under a lot of heat lately, with shares falling almost 20% over the past five trading sessions through Monday. On Monday, it was down more than 4.5% and nearing its 52-week lows, although so far on Tuesday it's getting a nice bounce back to $260. 

A blown settlement between the SEC and CEO Elon Musk led to a one-day 14% bludgeoning of the stock in late-September. That's all it took, as a day later shares were 17% higher after the parties agreed to a similar settlement.

Since then though, it's been a rough ride for the bulls. It's forcing some investors to look elsewhere for their do-good, all-electric car investments. While companies like General Motors (GM) - Get General Motors Company Report , Daimler (DDAIF) , Toyota (TM) - Get Toyota Motor Corp. Report and others have electric car offerings, none of them are quite like Tesla.

Except Nio (NIO) - Get NIO Inc. (China) Report .

Nio EP9

Debating a Buy in Nio?

Chinese electric vehicle maker Nio went public last month and has been on a whirlwind of a ride since. Volatility must come with the all-electric territory.

The company priced its stock at the low end of the range, between $6.25 and $8.25, as SoftBank (SFTBY) decided to skip an investment in the company's IPO. That's notable, as TheStreet has previously pointed out that SoftBank is becoming a leader in the future of auto thanks to its many investments in the industry.

On its first day of trading, Nio dropped to as low as $5.35, weakening confidence even more.

But that didn't last long. Shares hit $12.50 in its second session, almost doubling from the close on its first day of trading. Those gains extended to $13.85, the current 52-week high, the following day before embarking on a multi-week pullback.

TheStreet Recommends

Now trading at $6, investors contemplate a limited risk/reward play in the name. With its 52-week lows about 70 cents away, maybe it's not the worst buy in the world, particularly as Tesla stock continues its drumming. Then again, why buy Nio at a time where Tesla -- which produces and ships vastly more vehicles and is considered electric-vehicle leader -- can't even catch a bid?

Nio just began shipping its first vehicle in China earlier this summer. Through August, it has shipped less than 2,000 vehicles, less than Tesla manufacturers in a week at current rates.

In any regard, what's the upside? Nio sports a market cap of roughly $5 billion, a rather lofty mark considering that a company like General Motors trades with a market cap of "just" $48 billion. That's not stopping some analysts though, as the quiet period has ended and many are out with their ratings.

Morgan Stanley hit Nio with an overweight rating and $8.50 price target, while Deutsche Bank analysts assigned a buy rating and $9.50 price target, implying almost 60% upside. Goldman Sachs and Citigroup analysts both assigned a neutral rating, using price targets of $6.56 and $7.20, respectively. Even Goldman's price target -- the lowest of the group -- implies almost 10% upside from current levels.

On Tuesday, JPMorgan analysts assigned a neutral rating too, to go along with its $7.50 price target. Based on current prices, that implies more than 20% upside to current levels. Shares are currently changing hands near $6.17 in early Tuesday trading, likely getting a boost from the analysts' reports, which tilt slightly bullish. 

The valuation can be tough to swallow, even with Nio stock down at $6. For that matter, Tesla's valuation is tough too. For those that want to play the future of auto but don't want to pay a huge valuation, consider Alphabet (GOOGL) - Get Alphabet Inc. Class A Report (GOOG) - Get Alphabet Inc. Class C Report for Waymo, General Motors for Cruise (now valued at more than $14 billion!) and Nvidia (NVDA) - Get NVIDIA Corporation Report for its industry-leading hardware.

Want to Buy Stocks for a 10% or Greater Discount? You can with certain so-called "closed-end" mutual funds - an often overlooked investment class. Click here to register for a free online video in which TheStreet's retirement expert Robert Powell and an all-star panel run down all you need to know.

Alphabet is a holding in Jim Cramer's Action Alerts PLUS member club. Want to be alerted before Jim Cramer buys or sells GOOGL? Learn more now.

This article is commentary by an independent contributor. At the time of publication, the author had no positions in the stocks mentioned.