natural gas blowup could yet singe commodities broker
BMO, also known as Bank of Montreal, admitted Friday that it lost more than $300 million on natural gas trades that went bad.
Optionable, a Valhalla, N.Y., broker of energy options and derivatives trades to U.S. hedge funds and other financial institutions, said in a recent federal filing that BMO accounted for 24% of net revenue last year.
But that figure could significantly understate the extent of Optionable's dependence on Bank of Montreal, its largest customer, for business.
Optionable is in the business of finding so-called counterparties for energy trades -- meaning it matches buyers with sellers. The broker charges a commission to both parties.
A spokesman says counterparty deals represent 75% of Optionable's trading revenue. In such transactions, revenue from any given party represents just half of the company's potential revenues. That's a key point in assessing Optionable's dependence on BMO.
A look at Optionable filings from last year show that net revenue for 2006 was $16 million. Taking Optionable's 24% figure puts revenue from BMO at $3.8 million. That figure, in turn, represents 43% of the firm's $8.9 million in 2006 brokerage fees, according to filings with the
Securities and Exchange Commission
But remember, there are two sides to any counterparty deal. So trading deals involving BMO appear to account for 86% of the firm's brokerage fees, even if half of those fees aren't actually from BMO itself.
An external spokesman for Optionable agrees that BMO's impact is likely more than the 24% when factoring in counterparties. He says counterparty trading, in which Optionable gets paid on both sides, represents about three-quarters of its trading revenues. Floor trading makes up the remainder, says the spokesman, declining to provide a further breakdown of Optionable's business with BMO on the floor trades. In floor trades, brokers are only paid once, by the exchange.
Toronto-based BMO, which has been one of the more aggressive energy trading banks of its size, has said that its losses will be recorded on pretax basis in the second quarter of its 2007 fiscal year.
Although BMO chief Bill Downe described the losses as unacceptable, he didn't indicate that BMO would halt its energy trading operation, which has been a lucrative one before its blowup.
Nonetheless, if BMO finds it necessary to pull back significantly, Optionable could face a need to diversify.
In April, the
New York Mercantile Exchange
acquired a 19% stake in Optionable. Optionable's first-quarter earnings call will be held after the close of trading Tuesday.
Shares rose 9 cents over the counter Monday to $5.65.